health & development

Discipline: To Spank or Not to Spank?

Does spanking work, or is it counterproductive and traumatic? by The Babble Staff

November 27, 2006

Discipline: To Spank or Not to Spank?

ANTI-SPANKING

PRO-SPANKING

to be filled
DR. SEARS
to be filled
BABYCENTER®
to be filled
DR. SPOCK
to be filled
PARTNERSHIP FOR LEARNING
to be filled
CHRISTIAN PARENTS

THE BABBLE TAKE

Few things provoke as much anxiety as the realization that you are responsible for teaching another human being right from wrong. If you care enough to be reading this, you probably don't want your child to be the brat howling for ice cream in the grocery aisle, but you also don't want to raise a meek automaton whose sole reason for obeying authority is fear of punishment. The Christian Parents child-rearing primer accuses Dr. Spock of spoiling an entire generation of Americans with his council to spare the rod; they cite a few Bible verses as proof. On the other end of the spectrum, Dr. Sears claims that connection is key and that a "time out" may be too harsh and incomprehensible a punishment for a small child. The skeptic might wonder if Dr. Sears' assertion that staying "connected" to your child through attachment parenting is really going to cut it at more trying times. Yet most sense what Dr. Spock points out: meting out heavy punishment to a child whose understanding of right and wrong is yet unformed by social convention is not only mean but often unproductive. How to discipline a child without furnishing her with lifelong scars and traumatic horror stories to bring to the therapist is an age-old question. Here are some voices in the debate.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION IN OUR MESSAGE BOARD

  • to be filled

    CON: Dr. Sears "Top Ten Discipline Principles"

    [Teach your child] a method of releasing himself from an activity without resorting to a tantrum. That's what discipline is all about. Realizing how much better discipline worked when we considered our children's needs in our decisions was a major turning point for us. Initially, we had to work through the fear that we were letting our children manipulate us, because we had read, heard from others, and grown up with the idea that good parents are always in control. We found, however, that considering our child's point of view actually helped us take charge of them. Knowing our children became the key to knowing how to discipline them. They knew we were in charge because we were able to help them obey. That left no doubt in their minds or ours that Mom and Dad knew best. ...read the full article

  • to be filled

    CON: BabyCenter® "What's the Best Way to Discipline a Toddler?"

    Think of discipline as a form of teaching, not a form of punishment. Your child needs to learn how to get along with others and stay safe. He's an eager student, but the most important lessons — sharing, patience, cooperation, caution — will take a few years to sink in. As his main teacher, it's your job to reinforce the lessons with consistency, patience, and compassion.

    Time-outs can be helpful, but few children understand the concept until they're at least 3 years old. For a younger child, time-outs are confusing and frustrating. If your child is old enough to understand time-outs, use them sparingly and limit them to three minutes or less — just long enough for your child to get control of himself. Put him in a "naughty chair" instead of sending him to his room — you don't want him to associate his room with punishment. Consider sitting with him. He'll probably calm down faster, and you could use the break, too.

    No matter how badly your child is behaving, hitting shouldn't be an option. Spanks and slaps teach children to be afraid of their parents. And even though you would never intend to hurt your child, it's easy to lose control when you're angry. If you feel like hitting your child, give yourself a time-out until the feeling passes. ...read the full article

  • to be filled

    CON: Dr. Spock "What Spanking Accomplishes"

    Most — but not all — pediatricians and psychologists agree that spanking is not a desirable or particularly effective form of discipline. For example, the American Academy of Pediatrics' official policy says, in part:

    "Despite its common acceptance, spanking is a less effective strategy than timeout or removal of privileges for reducing undesired behavior in children. Although spanking may immediately reduce or stop an undesired behavior, its effectiveness decreases with subsequent use. The only way to maintain the initial effect of spanking is to systematically increase the intensity with which it is delivered, which can quickly escalate into abuse. Thus, at best, spanking is only effective when used in selective infrequent situations." ...read the full article

  • to be filled

    MIDDLE GROUND: Partnership for Learning

    To spank or not to spank?
    The question of how to discipline is not as simple as that. And neither is the answer. Some professionals get involved in arguments centered on spanking, and usually nothing useful comes of it. You know your child needs to be disciplined. So what do you do?

    First, set limits. Even the youngest child needs to know what is and is not allowed. Children need to know what you expect of them, and what the consequences are when they disobey.

    Second, be consistent. Children get confused when one day you enforce a rule, but the next day you ignore their behavior. [...] Be clear about the consequences, too. They need to know that they will always get whatever discipline you have set.

    Third, show respect for authority. Teach your child to be respectful of people who are in authority. That means they respect you, their friends' parents, and others. ...read the full article

  • to be filled

    PRO: Christian Parents: The World, the Word & You!

    I want to talk about the physical disciplining a child through parental authority. Now, if today's secular humanists are right, any form of hitting a child for any reason is wrong and an unlawful form of child abuse. Admittedly, a small portion of what some parents call spanking may actually be physical abuse that needs to be stopped and prevented from being carried out. But today I fear we have over-reacted to this abuse syndrome, and because of a deeper reason, many have rejected the age-old method of training children that has not only worked rightly, but is divinely approved by God Himself. ...read the full article

JOIN THE DISCUSSION IN OUR MESSAGE BOARD

BACK TO ALL TOPICS

New This Week