Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

health & development

Natural vs. Epidural

Read a range of expert opinions and get Babble's take by The Babble Staff

November 28, 2006

Natural Childbirth v. Epidural

ANTI-EPIDURAL

PRO-EPIDURAL

to be filled
DR. SEARS
to be filled
DR. SPOCK
to be filled
UTAH DEPT. HEALTH
to be filled
YAHOO! HEALTH
to be filled
US NEWS

THE BABBLE TAKE

For some mothers the choice is simple: they don't want to be in pain, so they want an epidural. Others don't mind the pain so much as the loss of feeling and control in the lower half of their body that comes from epidural anesthesia, so they opt for natural childbirth. Many women start out with every intention of having a drug-free birth but find that after twenty hours of labor, breathing and thinking happy thoughts no longer cuts it. Doctors will often recommend an epidural if they think labor is being slowed down by the mother's fatigue. Dr. Marjorie Greenfield says women may feel more in control when not in intense pain. On the other hand, not having an epidural means you will be able to walk around, change positions on your own and push more effectively. But new studies show an epidural doesn't increase the chance that vacuum, forceps, or C-sections will be needed during delivery, as has been reported. It really is your call.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION IN OUR MESSAGE BOARD

  • to be filled

    ANTI-EPIDURAL: Dr. Sears "Epidural"

    You can influence pain at three sites: where it's produced in the first place, at the gate in the spinal cord, and in the brain where the pain is perceived. In working out your own techniques for pain management, you will want to employ pain-relief measures that can control pain at all three of these sites. ...read the full article

  • to be filled

    MIDDLE GROUND: Dr. Spock "Natural Childbirth versus Epidural"

    An epidural generally takes away or at least diminishes the pain of contractions. When labor gets very intense in the active phase, and especially in transition, women with epidural anesthesia seem more relaxed and more "themselves." ...read the full article

  • to be filled

    MIDDLE GROUND: Utah Department of Health, Reproductive Health Program "Epidural Anesthesia and Childbirth: The Choice is Yours!"

    An epidural is a method of controlling pain during childbirth. A needle is first inserted into the epidural space that surrounds the spinal cord in the lower back. Then a small tube, or "catheter," is threaded through the needle into the space and the needle is removed. The catheter is securely taped to the back, and remains there until after the baby is born. Medication is given through the catheter to block the feeling of pain from the lower body. Even with the epidural in place, the mother-to-be should feel the pressure of contractions and have the urge to push when the time comes. ...read the full article

  • to be filled

    MIDDLE GROUND: Yahoo! Health "Should I use epidural anesthesia during childbirth?"

    Because epidural pain medication doesn't go directly into your bloodstream, your baby is unlikely to be affected. (Research data aren't yet clear enough to say that there are no effects.) By comparison, when medication is given through a vein ( intravenous, or IV) or by injection into a muscle (intramuscular), it travels to your baby across the placenta after an hour or so. If your baby is born before the medication wears off, he or she may suffer side effects such as breathing difficulty and grogginess (which are reversed at birth with another medication). ...read the full article

  • to be filled

    PRO-EPIDURAL: U.S. News and World Report-Best Health "Gimme that epidural: Epidural looks OK for moms-to-be, even early in labor"

    The women who got epidurals early in labor were no more likely to have cesareans. They weren't any more likely to need instruments for a vaginal delivery, either. Here's something else interesting: for women who had vaginal deliveries, the time from their first dose of pain medication to the birth was shorter if that first dose was an epidural. A lot shorter — the median time was 398 minutes for an epidural and 479 minutes if the first dose was the systemic pain relief. Women who had epidurals were also in less pain and were less likely to throw up than women who had the systemic pain relief. ...read the full article

JOIN THE DISCUSSION IN OUR MESSAGE BOARD

BACK TO ALL TOPICS

New This Week