Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

 

I lowered the carrier's canopy. The baby grunted awake. Evie stood up and I followed her back downstairs to Lisa.

Lisa was Evie's mother. I adored Lisa, just loved her. She was funny, open, smart and often exasperated just like me. She was one of the few mothers I'd met who I was completely at ease around. I was only a half-hearted user of the modern parenting vernacular, so when I was too tired for "I" statements or imploring my daughter to "use her words," around Lisa I wasn't embarrassed to tell Beatrice "No!" or "Quit whining." I told Lisa how I locked Beatrice out of my room to keep from coming unglued one afternoon. And how I shouted at her once so loud that I had a sore throat for two days. No gasps. No judgment. She got it. She made parenting drama feel less, well, dramatic.

Lisa and I met setting up for a rummage sale at our daughters' preschool. Pricing stacks of stained bedspreads could forge a bond even between polar opposites, but Lisa and I had much in common. We were new to a city where we were surrounded by wealth while our own families just got by. We were blue in a state of red. Lisa liked to read. I liked to write. She had mother problems. I had father problems. Our mutual attraction was instant. Girl crush? Maybe. It was just so easy with Lisa, easy and fun. We had the makings of Oprah and Gayle, without stylish pantsuits.

But we didn't come alone.We had the makings of Oprah and Gayle, without stylish pantsuits.

Behind a fold-out table of rummage-sale VCRs and gently used Naturalizer slip-ons, Lisa and I pointed at our daughters through a window to the playground. Beatrice held on tight in a swing, while another girl carefully pushed her higher. Evie was dumping wet sand and dirt at the bottom of a slide, while James stood at the top crying.

"That's mine over there," Lisa said, "playing with James."

Our first playdate: Lisa's house. Things fell apart quickly — screaming, tears, yanking, pouting. Anesthetizing them in front of a Little Bear DVD didn't help — Evie kicked at Beatrice until she cleared the three-seater sofa facing the screen. The girls were tired, I reasoned. And it's hard to share your own space and toys. The next time, we brought new ones, two of everything. Evie took both. The rest was a repeat.

We tried again, this time outside. In the wading pool, Evie blocked Beatrice from the tiny slide. She pushed her in the water, hogged the hose and threw grass. I tried getting Beatrice to stand up to her, to at least tell her "no," but it wasn't in her personality to fight back. In hindsight, she was probably scared.

This went on. Sure, Lisa did all the right things — time outs, consequences, "I" statements, words. Sometimes she unraveled and let loose an old-fashioned verbal smackdown. Lisa didn't flinch the few times I barked at Evie. But that was hard for me, disciplining a friend's kid. And draining. Plus, it never changed anything. Evie didn't sweat me.

Discuss this article (13)   |   PRINT THIS ARTICLE  |   EMAIL TO A FRIEND  |     RATE THIS NOW!
+ DIGG  |   + REDDIT  |   + DEL.ICIO.US  |   + MY YAHOO  |   + GOOGLE  |   RSS
 

About the Author

author bio Madeline Holler is a writer and mother of two. She lives in Long Beach, California.

New This Week



WELCOME! Sign in | Join | My Account


Daily Poll

What’s your opinion on home birth?


partner links