Strollerderby

Don't Ask If We're Trying to Have a Boy . . . or a Girl

Posted by JeanneSager

My friend cried hysterically when she found out her first baby was going to be a boy. Now, two boys later, she says she'd likely only get pregnant again if she could guarantee another boy.

So what's the most common question she's asked about the possibility of number three? "So, are you going to try for your girl?"

Writer Amy Wilson has written a compelling piece for Parenting Magazine about why that question comes so often for mothers of little boys . . . and why it's just so darn inappropriate.

"It bothers me that people assume I feel incomplete without a daughter, let alone that it's my motivation for being pregnant with a third child in the first place," she says.

I actually have a daughter, my one and only, and I get the opposite question: "when are you going to give her a little brother?" Or, maybe worse "when are you going to make your husband a little boy?"

Just as Wilson is disturbed by the notion that her life would be considered incomplete without a little girl, I wonder why a little boy is so necessary to round out a family. And why should I be putting the burden of being one or the other on this little fetus who really has no control.

Gender preferences are somewhat natural, don't get me wrong. There's the idea, as Wilson had, that you better understand the gender you have (with her, the boys) or the gender you are (why many women say they want a girl, many men say they're shooting for a boy). But those preferences will go away when a child comes along. They did for my friend. They did for Wilson, whose third baby, it turned out, was a little girl.

So why does the rest of the world seem to think we can't turn it off? Or assume it's there to begin with? I can honestly say I didn't know which (or I should say who) I wanted. I was equally excited and terrified by each gender. I'd changed boy diapers before, but never girls. But then again, I am a girl, I know how that works . . . and so forth. I worried about the still tenuous mother-daughter relationship I have with my mother. I worried about the father-son relationship my husband has with his dad. I thought about reading Anne of Green Gables with a little girl, about my friend's cuddly little ball of love of a boy.

And, in the end, I got a girl. A beautiful, sweet, sometimes drives me a little bonkers, girl. I wouldn't trade her in for a boy. I wouldn't replace her with a boy. And if I had it to do over, I might even find myself saying "yes, if we could guarantee another girl."

For those of us with one gender of children (be it one, two, three, etc.), it's really not the end of the world. Really. If anything, it's just the beginning.

Related Posts:

If You Had a Parenting Do-Over

Iowa Mulling Same Sex Birth Certificates?

Also on Babble:

One is the Awesomest Number

Pick a Sex, Any Sex



+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Jen said:

That article made me so mad.  What ridiculous stereotypes the author had about girls.  As the mother of 2 girls, I admit to being a bit biased about girls.  I will also say that neither of my girls are into princesses and are gentle and dainty little things as the author believes.  In fact, they're both very different from each other, perhaps even as different as a boy would be from a girl.

She says she won't be able to stomach daily viewings of the Little Mermaid, or she won't know what to do if her daughter wants a pink poodle party.  Geez, neither would I.  I hope the author's daughter defies these stereotypes even though it's clear this is what the author expects her daughter to be (buying pink clothes, for example).  If her daughter is anything like my oldest, she will not be a little angel quietly playing with her dolls on the floor, but rather a rough-and-tumble gregarious kid who just happens to be female.

May 1, 2009 2:45 PM
 

leahsmom said:

I didn't read the article, but Jen's comment made me a bit ruffled towards it - surely, the writer would hate people to make similar comments about her little boy?

People get to judge for themselves the completeness of their lives.  

May 1, 2009 3:11 PM
 

Musik_Grrrl said:

As the oldest of five girls I observed that every time my mom was pregnant people would ask her if she was trying for a boy.  My mom's response, "We are trying for a baby.  If I was only trying for a boy I would have stopped at three."  

May 1, 2009 5:01 PM
 

JJ said:

You know what I hate it when women dump on girly things. And there was an edge of that in the main article.

It’s as if we still haven’t gotten past this idea that being a girl is somehow not as good.  Now girls can only be awesome if they defy our expectations. Heaven forfend a girl actually likes dolls or adores pink or wants to dress all frilly! Loving your child as he or she is doesn’t mean you have to dump on little girls who may be different.

What’s wrong with a pink poodle party? Sounds adorable to me, if it is appreciated by the birthday girl. In fact, I want a pink poodle party for my next birthday!  There had better be matching napkins!  

As for buying a pink baby sweater, what’s so horrible about adhering to the social code that says to passers by - "This baby is a girl"? It’s not like a newborn can like or hate pink. I do know one couple who dresses their toddler girl (named Ryann) like a little boy.  Yet they always get annoyed when people mistake Ryann for a boy.  Now that is ridiculous!

May 1, 2009 5:23 PM
 

J said:

We have one of each, which I'm thrilled with, though I would have been equally thrilled with two boys or girls.  Now people make comments along the lines of "Great, you have one of each!  Now you can be done!" as though the only reason to want a third baby is to get the gender you don't have.  We want a third (and fourth) because we love kids and would enjoy having more!

May 1, 2009 5:32 PM
 

angry said:

And can I point out the rather obvious problem, referenced by JJ, with a woman saying "Oh, I'd hate to have DAUGHTERS because they might like GIRL THINGS and GIRL THINGS are STUPID AND AWFUL EWWWeleventyone." We have a feminist problem there, and we also have just a sensibility problem.  Shame on her.

May 1, 2009 5:57 PM
 

Sheri said:

I got that question all the time too....I would just say I wanted a healthy baby.  

May 1, 2009 6:11 PM
 

Marj said:

I'm expecting two boys in August.  I get a lot of questions about when I'm going try for that girl.  Well, I wanted two children, I'm having two children and I'm done.  Do I feel a little wistful?  Sometimes, but only because I have such a wonderful relationship with my own mother.  I get a little misty over the mother/daughter moments we've had that I won't get to have.  But then I remember having a girl wouldn't have garanteed those either.  So, I'll be happy with my two boys.  We don't need gender balance to have a complete family.

May 1, 2009 6:39 PM
 

ChiLaura said:

I have two boys and am pregnant with our third. I love boys and think that boys are great. But let me tell you, I'm HOPING so much that we're having a girl this time. Pink dresses? Tights? Purple ruffles? Bring it on! She can grow up however she wants to -- tomboy, princess, whatever -- but until she can dress herself, I'm going all out. I'm mentally prepping for a son, though. And I'm fairly certain that we will be having a fourth, regardless of the result. =)

May 1, 2009 10:38 PM
 

GiantPanda said:

People don't realise sometimes how much pressure and stress they can cause. For my first child, my family made it well known that they were all looking forward to a little girl - he turned out to be a boy. Now I am pregnant with a second, my mother has already given me a bunch of little pink jumpsuits and little pink shoes, so I haven't told them yet that I am expecting another boy. I love my son to pieces, and I know I'll love his brother as well, but I had a moment of mourning for the daughter I was kind of hoping for, and my mother and sisters make me feel even worse.

May 2, 2009 3:16 AM
 

Courtney said:

I'm currently pregnant with boy number two.  I never had a preference either way for this pregnancy or the last one, but I constantly had people asking what I wanted.  My response was always "a baby.  I'll be really pissed if it's a puppy in there."

They'd laugh and then ask, "no really?"

It seems like such strange question to me.  Even if you do have a strong preference, if it turns out that you are having the opposite, are they planning on reminding you of the conversation?  Are they going to give you condolences or something?  I never ask people what they want, only if they are planning on finding out or not.

May 2, 2009 4:12 PM
 

Robyn said:

My son and I went shopping for princess clothes this morning. He loves to play dress up, whether he's Thomas the Tank Engine, Cookie Monster, or Princess Pea from Super Why. He loves all of the Disney stories, including The Little Mermaid and Beauty and the Beast.

It actually bothers me when people "try" for a specific gender. If a person really wants a boy or a girl guaranteed, then adopt. We know we're having a girl next time.

May 2, 2009 6:44 PM
 

Sue said:

JJ I had to laugh (in agreement) with your comments!  And, is the author implying that she would be bothered if she had a son with (what we consider) feminine preferences and asked for a "pink poodle party"?

Maybe society hasn't come so far after all.

May 3, 2009 8:37 PM
 

JeanneSager said:

JJ, Angry, et al: I hear you! I am not a girly girl. My daughter is. And I've learned to live with it! Sometimes we have to let go of "feminist ideals" and just let kids follow their natural tendencies. She has a LOT of trucks, and she loves to play with them. But she also loves to play with her very poofy princess dresses.

May 3, 2009 8:52 PM
 

Treespeed said:

ChiLaura,

sometimes they start deciding what they are going to wear before they can dress themselves. Just because they can't put on their clothes, doesn't mean they can't stop you from putting something on them they don't like. Our very active girl would not let us put in her pants after a certain age, thank goodness for heavy duty tights.

We never had that question and it would be very hard for me not to reply with a MYOB.

May 4, 2009 6:37 PM
 

JJ said:

I'm sorry but I'm not sure it where it says "can't like dolls or frilly things" and "must like only trucks and trains" in the feminist handbook.  Perhaps that chapter didn't make it into my copy.  What will I do with all my doll collection?  I never realized they were ruining my feminist cred.

Ironically, I think there's a streak of families who are more comfortable when their sons enjoy filly dresses (not that there's anything wrong with that).  Heaven forbid their girls do.  Someone might think she's average and lame.  Talk about pressure!

May 5, 2009 3:11 PM
 

Angus said:

I guess I'll be the lone poster willing to admit to desiring a daughter this time after two boys.  I'm having another boy.

I've also had two miscarriages so I do suspect that I cannot carry a girl.  Doesn't make me mourn the daughter I'll never have any less.

My mom raised my sister and I alone and I think that absolutly contributed to my wanting a daughter.  I just never imagined I wouldn't have one.  Of course I love my sons, wouldn't trade them for 100000000000 girls.  It doesn't make me a bad mother or person to want a daughter.

May 5, 2009 7:40 PM
 

desolateyetallundaunted said:

What's wrong with pink and dolls, ponies and the princesses? Why can't you be a feminist and still like these things? I have a son and am hoping for a little girl next time, and I hope that my little girl likes to do "girly" things, because I do to, and maybe we can do mother-daughter things? But some people tend to be so femenistic that they consider anyone who actually likes to conform to the traditional gender roles to be evil. For example: I LIKE being a stay at home mom, just because I am a stay at home mom, however, dosen't mean that I think that ALL women have to be SAHM's or that this is my "proper" place, I could work if I wanted to, but I don't WANT to. This doesn't make me anti feminist and neither does a little boy thinking dolls are boring or a little girl insisting her room be done in pink.

May 16, 2009 1:55 PM

About JeanneSager

Jeanne Sager is a writer who lives in upstate New York with her husband, daughter, a dog and too many cats. She refuses to believe motherhood comes with pumpkin appliqued sweaters, and she';s not ready to apologize for having only one child. She writes about raising her kid in her own hometown and the mom stuff she's not embarrassed to own at her blog, Inside Out (http://jeannesager.blogspot.com), she's contributing editor of Grand Magazine, and she's a regular essayist here on Babble

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage