Strollerderby

Toddlers Whose Parents Hit Have More Trouble Sleeping

I’m hoping it won’t surprise you to learn that a three-year study of 4,600 toddlers has concluded that children whose parents hit or yell at them are more likely to have trouble sleeping. It doesn't take an expert to realize that a quick slap and a screamed threat are not exactly relaxing.

What is surprising is that the Australian pediatrician who led the study is arguing that there is no way to know whether aggressive parenting causes sleeping problems, or if toddlers who are cranky and overtired cause their parents to be more hostile."It's always a cause-and-effect argument and you can't really conclude from this which occurs first," said Dr. Harriet Hiscock.

Call me naïve, but I kinda thought it was common knowledge that, “He made me do it!” is not a justifiable excuse for violence—particularly when the “he” is a toddler. Furthermore, the study—which examined sleeping habits when children were one-year-old, and then again two years later—found that “mothers' parenting style was not a big factor in sleep problems at the age of one, but became an issue by the second study.”

Hmmm, I wonder if the inability to fall asleep that these kids developed over time had anything to do with living with the constant stress of parents who frequently lose their tempers….

Photo: Hank van Stuivenberg/Sydney Morning Herald

Related Post:

Another Country Bans Spanking



+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

crabmommy said:

"Yelling" causes sleep problems? Give me a break. And okay, so "hitting" is "violence"-- I assume you must mean all forms of hitting, even a spank here or there.

My child has been a fabulous sleeper all of her life. Even though I yell sometimes. And I went through a phase with her where a bit of spanking was something I chose to use (sparingly, but I did spank). She has always slept "like a baby." I guess you'll find a study to prove that she did that so as to psychologically escape the presence of her abusive mother. So be it--if that's the case, it worked like a charm.

April 7, 2009 1:44 PM
 

diera said:

I don't think that they're saying that the parents are justified in hitting the toddlers if the toddlers sleep poorly.  They're just saying that, once again, you cannot make a conclusion about a causal relationship because of an observed correlation.  If hitting and sleep problems are observed to be correlated, it could mean that hitting leads sleep problems, or sleep problems lead to hitting, or a third factor causes both (maybe both parents and children have ADHD, for example, which could cause sleep problems in the children and poor impulse control in the adults).  If you're going to design effective interventions, you need to know what is really causing what, and the researcher is saying that you can't conclude that from his study.  Kudos to him for pointing that out.

April 7, 2009 1:45 PM
 

diera said:

P.S.  Your title - "Hitting Leads To Sleep Problems" - is precisely what the researcher is saying you can't conclude from his work.  "Hitting Associated With Sleep Problems" would be much less misleading.

April 7, 2009 1:50 PM
 

Lisa said:

I'll add one other possibility... it is entirely possible that the child's sleep problems are leading to sleep loss in the parent which leads to poor parental self control.

Diera is right.. we have no causal information, only a relationship.

April 7, 2009 2:14 PM
 

Hannah Tennant-Moore said:

Good point about the title, Diera.  I've changed it.

April 7, 2009 2:34 PM
 

david said:

If you're interested in discovering your parenting style based on the latest research, please check out the <a href="www.parenting.com/.../signalPatterns.jsp">Parenting Style Application</a> by Signal Patterns on Parenting.com.

The underlying model developed by our team of psychologists reveals an underlying complexity far richer than just 'strict' or 'relaxed' classifications.

And what's particularly interesting is that you can take the test for a spouse and see where potential conflicts might lie and get advice on how to deal w/them.  You can also compare results to your friends'.

April 8, 2009 12:58 PM
 

Meg said:

Crabmommy,

Anecdotal evidence is a logical fallacy. (In other words, a sample size of 4600 is much more accurate than a sample size of 1.) How can the knowledge "crabmommy's kid was spanked and slept OK" be helpful to sociologists? By itself, it's pretty meaningless -- all it tells us is that there are outliers, which is true for every correlation. They're looking at a general, average case, because general, average cases are more meaningful.

April 10, 2009 12:11 AM

About Hannah Tennant-Moore

Hannah Tennant-Moore is a Brooklyn-based freelance writer whose work has appeared or is forthcoming in Best Buddhist Writing (2008); The Sun; Guantanamo: Inside the Prison, Outside the Law; Tricycle; Turning Wheel (as the winner of the Young Writers Award); and elsewhere.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage