Strollerderby

Husband Loses Job, Wife Loses Respect For Him

Posted by Brett Singer

This wife lost respect for her husband when he lost his job. He was laid off.We all know how tough it is out there. The number of jobs is shrinking by the day, and layoffs are common. Many families still follow the traditional model where the husband is the breadwinner and the wife takes care of the children and housekeeping duties. Nothing wrong with that. But let's say dad loses his job. He didn't quit because he missed out on a promotion, nor was he fired for making photocopies of his butt. He was laid off. It happens. Mom should be supportive, right? Flexible. Do what needs to be done to keep the family together.

Well, yes. Of course. But in the case of this couple that was profiled on ABC's Good Morning America, wifey has lost respect for her fella. She's not attracted to him anymore. In fact, they are sleeping in separate beds.

The wife in question, Eleanor Hemmert, had this to say about her husband Rick: "It's the respect. I wish I could say something different, but I've lost so much respect for him. And I think the dynamics with a man and a woman is a woman has to respect her husband. And if she doesn't, that relationship just goes away."

In an illustration of what I meant when I questioned a passage from Kate Gosselin's book, Eleanor also said: "That's one of the basic things that little girls grow up thinking - that the man is going to put the roof over her head, he is going to support the family." And when it doesn't happen, you get angry. Expectations can be bad when the person is inflexible.

I'm not in their marriage, so I don't know what else is going on. But this couple chose to put themselves on TV, so I'm commenting.  Anytime I hear a woman complain that her husband isn't doing the manly work that she expects her man to be doing, it really irks me.  If a woman were told to stay home and get pregnant, and that her place was in the kitchen, preferably barefoot, would she like that? Or that it was perfectly reasonable to pay her less money than a man who does the same job? Granted, those things happen all the time. But they're wrong. So is this woman's attitude.

Of course, Husband Rick isn't helping matters. "I think it is in every man's DNA to be the breadwinner. It's very humbling for me. It changes the dynamic of our relationship immensely. There is a wedge that has appeared. I feel the anger. I feel the tension. This house is not as joyous as it should be."

See, that's a choice. It's not in any man's "DNA" that he has "to be the breadwinner." It's in his mind, and the mind of his wife. Sometimes things change. Is it unpleasant? Sure. Is it worth ruining your marriage for? No way.

I understand that it's probably very frustrating for any couple when the primary breadwinner loses their job. But it's not like Mr. Man decided to quit being a salesman in order to pursue his dream of being a rodeo clown. Wife Eleanor is also complaining that she has to work more hours now, and that Rick cooks dinner poorly. But is that really fair? If he's just sitting around the house all day with his feet up, I can see being annoyed about that. But that's different from being so furious about something that was outside of you and your husband's control that you can't even sleep in the same room anymore.

Their daughter Elizabeth is "picking up" the tension between mom and dad. While both husband and wife are angry at each other and feel "underappreciated", their daughter is "suffering silently," says ABC News. "If the kids sense that you are unhappy and you don't talk to them about it, they may incorrectly blame themselves," they say. Good advice. Maybe the Hemmerts will take it.

Source: ABC News

Read more:

Open Letter To The Woman Who Pushed Me While I Was Picking Up My Kid

Morning News - iPhone Gets Feature Other Phones Already Have

UPDATE - Josef Fritzl Sentenced To Life In Psychiatric Institution

Kate Gosselin Dreamt Of A Husband and Children - Did You?

They Say - Older Fathers Spawn Dumber Kids

GMA Tweets Details On Levi Johnston And Son

4 Year Old Brings Pot To School, School Bans Backpacks

Oprah Gets It Right On Chris Brown


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

JeanneSager said:

If women who DO stay at home are ever going to get people to understand that what they do is important too, they need to realize it's a two-way street. Whoever is at home is important, whether it's Mom or Dad.  

And the idea that a guy losing his job in a poor economy means he's failing his family shows this woman lacks a grasp on how the real world works. It's called being part of a family, honey, increasing your hours when your husband loses his job.

March 22, 2009 6:21 PM
 

Laure68 said:

There is still so much pressure in this society for the man to have more money than the woman. For a first date, everyone assumes the man will pay, if not for all of the dates. When I was single I made a very good living. I dated quite a few men who made less than me. I never liked the idea that the man should pay all the time, because that made me feel like some kind of owned object, so I paid half the time we went out. You wouldn't believe how many people told me that I must not have enough self respect! And this mostly came from male friends. I was told so often that the man should always pay, and should be the main breadwinner in a family.

I think this idea is stupid. I always wanted to have an equal relationship, and did not want to be financially dependent on anyone. However, if this is what other people were telling me, than I am sure this woman has heard the same throughout her life. I'm not trying to defend her, but I think this couple is saying what a lot of people are really thinking on the inside.

March 22, 2009 9:18 PM
 

Manjari said:

This woman is awful, and her husband has the wrong idea too. What is wrong with people?

March 22, 2009 10:08 PM
 

Alice said:

I can understand why he feels depressed.  A real man cares for his wife and kids.  He is an adult.  There are too many children out there who call themselves men who do not care for their offspring or even marry thier mother.  Adult men take resposibility seriously.  This man does.  They will work it out.  If not she had better watch it.  He is pretty dishy!

March 22, 2009 10:52 PM
 

Twyla said:

My husband lost his job when we first moved in together. The boss told all the workers one night that he was closing shop. That was thier last day of work. It was horrible. I was pregnant and now we had a rent to pay along with taking care of our two kids. My husband first thought he would try the unemployment thing. That lasted about one day. He felt gross staying home when he had a family to support. I was supportive of either thing he wanted to do but he could not stand it. He had a job within two weeks.

I understand how he feels. However, she is being a bit unreasonable. Financial stress will make you crazy. Maybe that is the problem.

March 23, 2009 12:14 AM
 

g8grl said:

Hard to say what is between a husband and wife but I will say that they're lucky they found each other because they seem to have the same expectations.  I guess that's what folks would call a good match.  Their problem is that they're both not flexible to deal with the disappointment of him not meeting their expectations, but again, that's probably why they're a good match for each other.  Truth is the truth.  When I was dating I went out with a man who made $$80K less than I did.  Awkward.  He didn't like it and neither did I.  I felt guilty when he paid and he felt diminished when I paid.  Not a good match.  

March 23, 2009 12:33 AM
 

leahsmom said:

I'm kind of with g8grl - this seems like one of those marriages where the business deal is clear - he earns the cash and goes out with the boys; she stays at home and raises the kids. If one of them stops doing that, the whole thing falls apart. It's not at all the way I'd want to live or the way my marriage is - my husband lost his job a few weeks ago, and we can make it on his savings and my salary; I think no less of him, and am actually glad he gets to be at home more for a while.

March 23, 2009 8:52 AM
 

KT said:

My problem with this couple is that they had marital problems long before the husband lost his job.  They say in the segment that they have been sleeping in separate rooms for over 3 years, yet the husband only lost his job a few months ago.  So they have nothing to do with one another.  I just wish the news wouldn't find the most EXTREME example and then run with it like every family in the same role switching situation has the same extreme problems.

March 23, 2009 1:17 PM
 

mchaos said:

My husband was laid off, and he is working so hard at finding a new job that I have all-new respect for him.  He's looking into different kinds of jobs, he's taking classes at the Unemployment center and he trying to get fit to help in one of his possible options.  He is the hardest working unemployed man I've ever seen, and I'm glad he is my life partner.

March 23, 2009 3:10 PM
 

Sue said:

Photocopies of his butt! LOL!  Okay I'll read the rest of it now.

March 23, 2009 10:53 PM
 

Jason said:

I lost my job, house, and my wife and kids ended up moving in with her parents. I moved in with a buddy. Since then I've had a job or two, now again I am Unemployed.

   I love my family. Times have been tough. Now she says she does'nt respect me. I've been married to her for 10 years. Our son is 6. We had the greatest relationship the first 8. All this time and now she doesn't respect me? Oh but when daddy is making money everything is o.k.? I didn't know that money meant so much. It totally changed my wifes mind. WTF?

April 13, 2009 12:44 AM

About Brett Singer

Brett Singer is a writer and father living in Manhattan with his wonderful wife and two terrific sons (referred to here as Thing 1 and Thing 2). He writes about music for the Boston Phoenix, parenting for Babble and daddytips.com, and other topics for anyone else who will have him.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage