Strollerderby

Boomer Grandmothers: Out of Control?

Posted by Kate Tuttle

You knew it had to happen. As the baby boom generation continues its lifelong parade of self-obsession, marveling at each passing milestone as if they were the first and only people to achieve them, it was inevitable that grandparenting, now that the boomers are entering the 60+ territory, would become their frontier and muse.

Some of this is downright terrifying, especially to those who were the children of baby boomers and are now trying to be, you know, parents. As we navigate pregnancy, childbirth, those early infant days and the growth of our toddlers and preschoolers, the last thing we need is the presence of our mother or mother-in-law making it all about her. I mean, heck yes, if your child has a grandmother who wants to help – from babysitting to pampering the new mom to contributing to the 329 plan – that’s great. But the boomer grandmothers often have a different agenda. They want complete access to their grandchild, whether they’re going to help or not. They want to offer endless advice and expertise, which they somehow think is different than the advice and expertise that bugged them when offered 30-some years ago by their own parents (because they think they’re cool, they came of age in the 60s, blah blah blah). They want, at least some of them, a grandmother shower so that they receive gifts and accolades for an accomplishment that, somehow, previous generations took for granted.

A new anthology allows these boomer grannies to fully express their awe and amazement at having reached this point in their lives.  Eye of My Heart: The Hidden Perils and Pleasures of Being a Grandmother comes out next month, with essays by nearly thirty writers, including Elizabeth Berg, Lynne Sharon Schwartz, Bharati Mukherjee, and Jill Nelson. Some are predictably cringe-worthy, as when Anne Roiphe writes about how she’s learned not to give advice to her daughters as they raise their babies – as if she deserves a medal for not pointing out that back in her day, babies didn’t need car seats. But most are very sweet and a few will take your breath away, as when Molly Giles writes about visiting her imperious, persnickety niece in Europe. Or when Susan Shreve describes the time-warping nature of life with small children, after she takes her grandson Theo for a day:

…I didn’t remember what a whole day with a child was like. The first day I had Theo to myself in New York it felt like a month. (This, even though with my own children it seemed as if the whole of their childhoods from start to finish had been over in a heartbeat.)

Anthology editor Barbara Graham sums it up in a way that made me wish she were my mother-in-law when she says that her son and his wife “are writing their own story – and though I’m certain to show up in the unfolding plot, I am not a central character.” I’m guessing she didn’t feel the need for a grandmother shower – and I’m guessing she’s a pretty wonderful grandmother.

 

More by this author:

Move Over, Booties! Here Come Knitted Boobies

Think Your Baby's Car Seat Is Safe? Think Again

California Daycare Closed; Worker Was Mocking Kids' Genitals

 "Angels in Waiting" Apparently Still Waiting

 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Leila said:

Since I lost my mother 3 years before my son was born, it really annoys me to read and hear people complaining about overinvolved grandmothers. Especially since the grandma and stepgrandma on my husband's side have never even offered to babysit once.

I'd take one of those self-indulgent boomer grandmas in a minute.

March 16, 2009 1:44 PM
 

C.G said:

Leila while I feel for your situation, as it is very hard to lose a parent, and to have IL's who don't put the effort in.

But. Constantly being nagged, and harped on, and guilt tripped because you don't let them have overnights with the baby, you don't call enough, come over enough, we should have gotten married when we got pregnant because OMG people are going to think poorly of HER! I don't the kids hair right, bath him/her often enough, dress him/her right, they need a hat, they need mittens, they would look so much cuter in GREEN instead of purple! I want to feed the baby! When are you going to wean the baby? In my day the baby had cereal in his/her bottle at 1 week old and HE was just FINE. Give him/her this, give him/her that, on and on etc etc.

Trust me, as someone with a MIL who causes a lot of issues, it gets old really fast.

March 16, 2009 4:02 PM
 

elohveeee12 said:

C.G - Omg, the whole "getting married because people will think poorly of her" thing. People have said that to me on more than one occasion. or the slightly similar "what will she think of you when she is older!?!" thankfully not my own mother, though I know she feels that way, she manages to keep it to herself. but uncles, aunts, friends, my father, stepfather. everyone of them sees fit to jump in with that piece of info.

And once, when i used to cosleep, my stepMIL came over (and walked in because no one answered the door when she knocked... HELLOOO we were sleeping!!) and she took my daughter out of my bed while i was sleeping! and when i brought it up months later, she just shrugged. she did not think there was anything wrong with it.

the good news is, one day while she was visiting (after i asked her not to come over because i was busy that day), I snapped and flipped on her. she hasnt been over since. oh, and we moved two weeks ago, and she doesnt know where, lol. i am still laughing about that.

March 17, 2009 12:05 AM
 

e said:

Oh my, this describes my mother WAY too perfectly. My partner and I continually say, "thank goodness we live far away." I know she's trying to help, but she just doesn't get us, at all. Why are we cloth diapering? Why make our own food when we could just buy jars? Why are we still breastfeeding at nine months? We're not REALLY going to raise him as a vegetarian, are we? She actually cried inconsolably when she saw me swaddling my newborn and told me it was like "a baby straight jacket." The breaking point came when she came to visit and didn't like that we were putting our 2-month old boy in a hand-me-down pink sleeper at night. Apparently that will give him a "gender identity disorder."

Argh.

She tells me at least once a week that she loves my son more than I do because she's the grandmother, and I just have no idea what that kind of love is. Everything is always all about her and it's totally exhausting.

At least now I have a reason for it... she's a baby boomer!  

March 17, 2009 9:50 AM
 

patricia said:

OMG, e, the "baby strait jacket"!  I just had our second baby, and my in-laws were in town to help, mostly with my oldest.  But I can't count the number of times my MIL commented about the swaddle, that it's like a baby strait jacket.  Funnily enough, when I left the baby with my in-laws briefly to attend to my older child, I later heard that she insisted that my FIL swaddle the baby!

But my in-laws aren't the self-absorbed ones.  That would be my parents, who aren't interested in helping and can only give me endless grief about not bringing the kids to see them often enough.  

March 17, 2009 12:41 PM
 

Katie said:

Ok let's stop generalizing about a whole generation here.  As a new BabyBoomer grandparent,I think what you are experiencing here is typical MIL/Parental meddling, which has been going on forever, within all of the generations. I had trouble with mine as well. I am trying not to be that grandmother, but as the current generation of mothers and fathers are a bit older than I was during my childrearing years, I was worried that I would not be a grandparent at all! I am grateful for the little soul, who is my grandson and love him with all my heart, and will help and advise whenever asked. I have during the pregnancy read as much as I could about the new childrearing theories on this and other websites, just so I would not be the grandmother horrified about swaddling or co-sleeping or whatever. I am too busy with own life to meddle in my kid's life.

March 17, 2009 3:40 PM
 

Angus said:

I think so SO many of the "problems" we have with our parents and IL's is caused by the amount of research we do today in regards to everything child related.  We have thousands of books written by hundreds of "experts" and so many websites we could entertain ourselves for all of those sleepless nights and more.  

We don't just take our advice from our mothers and their mothers.  And since we are the first generation to really do this, I can see why this can cause friction.

Throw in how many dual income families rely on family to care for their kids, often for free, when our own parents are still young and vibrant.  It's no wonder why they perhaps feel they are "owed" more than expectations in return.

All parties could do well to bite their tongues from time to time, perhaps especially when child safety is not at risk.  Also, we could learn to take advice as that, not criticism.  

Signed, a 32yr old soon to be mother of three who has a good relationship with her own mother, asks for occasional babysitting and respects her life as her own.  IL's are far away and have their own health issues which preclude them from the long term childcare they'd be suitable for.

March 18, 2009 12:48 AM
 

Olya Fessard said:

This issue has nothing to do with a "boomer/all about me" generation, in my opinion. I publish a parenting magazine which requires that I stay up with all the latest "expert" opinions on child rearing, and yet, my daughter with whom I have always had a better-than-average relationship is extremely upset when I offer unasked-for baby advice.

My first grandchild was born a month ago, and my daughter still wants me to stay to keep the baby overnight so that she can get some rest. She had a rough delivery, and since she is the most important thing in my life, I am happy, no grateful, to be able to do this--even though my business is suffering from neglect. How many grandmothers have the pleasure of seeing all those wonderful changes in their grandbaby during the first few weeks?

The first week or two, my daughter became infuriated with me for giving unrequested advice. I was shocked since I was only wanting to help her. But I finally realized that I needed to make no comment re. baby unless she expressedly asked for my advice. She agreed that would be a good idea. It's working.

I believe this conflict happens for three reasons (excluding the rare, truly selfish, intrusive mothers or MIL's):

1) New moms have just gone through childbirth, hormones are raging, and they are, naturally, more irritable than usual.

2) Mothers love their daughters so deeply that they want their daughter's to have optimum success in their new role as parent. Consequently, they have an innate desire to try to help make that happen. And it's too easy to forget that our daughter's have millions of other resources today for parenting info. Plus in our case, I am ADHD, i.e., impulsive, often speaking without thinking how it might affect the other person!

3) Young people, also by their nature, want and need to feel in control of their own lives. They deserve that, so it's a positive thing. The negative that comes into play, as my daughter volunteered, is that she feels that a comment, fringing on advice, is insulting, that it is a statement about her inability to parent. As she said, she is a Leo, so what can we expect?

It is new issue that needs to be addressed more by psychologists, psychiatrists, and sociologist. It is sad for me to read what I assume is representative of young parents today--that they feel so much animosity.

The bottom line is that most grandmothers, like me, would give their lives for their daughters (as you will soon see), so they certainly would not intentionally hurt them.

March 24, 2009 5:09 AM
 

CV said:

I have to agree with CG - I have a MIL who believes that breastfeeding is disgusting and cannot believe that I'm doing such a gross thing with her grandchild.  I am sick of the constant go-go-go-go "I have to see him daily" (We do not live in town.  We live an hour away.) visits and command performances.  I am sick of them inviting themselves to our house for dinner on a work night even after we tell them "no".  They show up anyways.  That I'm awful for working.

And this after me screaming through gritted teeth to "get out get out GET OUT" as she waltzed into my room while I was in labor, after my husband and I specifically stated to all family "no, we want it to be US, no visitors til AFTER the baby is born and we've had a few hours to recoup and figure out the feeding thing".  Apparently it did not apply to HER.  

All of this after having ZERO MIL issues for the first few years of marriage.

March 30, 2009 3:36 PM

About Kate Tuttle

I'm raising a toddler and a teenager in a leafy suburb just outside Boston. In between having kids I've been an editor and writer, most recently with the African American National Biography and the late great Africana.com.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage