Strollerderby

They Say: Early Childhood Stress Negatively Affects Health for Life

Posted by Shannon LC Cate

Parents of children adopted as older babies or toddlers from institutional care settings have a lot on their plate.  They have to assess the child's immediate physical needs which could include malnutrition, undiagnosed diseases and developmental gaps, all depending on the quality of care the child has been receiving and for how long.  In addition to these physical concerns, adoptive parents of older children must work hard to create safe, nurturing environments and healthy emotional attachments for their kids.

The good news is that thousands of parents do this all quite successfully every year.

The bad news is that researchers are beginning to suspect that even once these things are addressed, children who began life in stressful conditions--particularly institutional care--have ongoing, lifelong health concerns.

The alarming study found that:

"Even the health of children adopted before the age of 3 who then spent more than a decade with their new families was no better than the health of children who had spent their entire childhoods in abusive families."

The study was done at the Child Emotion Laboratory in the University of Wisconsin-Madison Waisman Center by Seth Pollak, Elizabeth Shirtcliff and Christopher Coe.  It  measured immunity by comparing teens adopted from institutions as young children, teens raised in abusive families and teens from a control group.  By comparing the teens' levels of antibodies for the herpes simplex virus, they found that children living in abusive situations and children living in healthy families but with a history of institutionalization had similar immune responses to the latent virus.

The researchers conclude that children under stress have compromised immune systems, putting them at risk for other health problems throughout their lives.

Hopefully, learning about this phenomenon will help doctors whose patients have these kinds of early childhood stress histories.  Researcher, Christopher Coe advises the thousands of international and foster-adoptive parents out there to "go into adoption with your eyes wide open...[and] love these children. Give them all the support they need."

See also:

Disabled Children Removed from Care of "Compulsive" Foster Mom

image: gleasonworks.com


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

leahsmom said:

That's interesting - if it holds up scientifically, it would be interesting to see if there is a higher incidence of immune-related diseases (diabetes, celiac, lupus) among older adoptees or children with difficult backgrounds.

I hasten to point out, though, that compromised immunity or not, kids who are adopted into loving homes at any age are going to have a number of strong benefits to that, especially if they came from an abusive place.

February 4, 2009 12:00 PM
 

Sue said:

I've found this to overall be true in our 7 adopted children (most of whom arrived at an older age with significant health issues to begin with).

February 4, 2009 12:14 PM
 

Alice said:

My adopted kids are all healthier than my bio kids. So it is not true for us.  Does the study also take into account being raised in poverty with ppor nutrition and/or medical care?  People who are very poor have poorer health.  Being raised in a third world orphanage with scarce food, no heat, no hot water, dirty conditions would cause compromised the health as a baby which naturally affects the immune system fo rlife.  I think most people who adopt know this already and are prepared for this.  The same is true for people raised in poverty.  That photo looks exactly like the sleeping room of my youngest daughter China orphanage by the way. When I visited there were 2-3 babies in each bed all between 6-12 months of age.  

February 4, 2009 1:49 PM
 

Shannon LC Cate said:

Alice, you can check out the whole article in the link.  But the study didn't suggest the children would necessarily be unhealthy on any given day.  It measured the level of antibodies in children from the three groups--currently abused, institutional past, and non-abused without an institutional past.

They found that the children who were adopted after 6 months old had similar immunity patterns as those who were currently in abusive situations.

The adopted children were all in very healthy, well-off, stable families now and had been so for a minimum of three years.  The study's surprise was not that the physical health of the children was effected by poverty and early stress, but that children who now had plenty and seemingly little cause of stress still experienced high stress and therefore compromised immunity.

leah'smom, I in no way would suggest people not adopt because of this study.  I have two adopted children and will probably adopt a third, from about as high-stress a situation as I've seen, in fact.  I think the take-away from this study is to remember that love is a terrific starting place, but it is to enough to address the issues some adopted children will face.  We need to use that love for our kids to make sure no one lets them slip through cracks that might not always seem obvious.

February 4, 2009 2:04 PM
 

Sue said:

Shannon, more education is needed on this, keep posting these things. I've had nurses and school officials question my fitness as a parent, when there were a few months (awhile ago) when I kept having to bring one child after another to the pediatrician for seemingly unending illnesses.  There can be little understanding even among professionals about the ongoing physical and emotional issues faced by families who adopt older and/or disabled children (speaking generally).

February 5, 2009 8:56 AM
 

Simplex said:

Most children are infected by herpes in kindergarten, whether or not they have a parents

February 6, 2009 12:48 PM
 

Shannon LC Cate said:

simplex, that's why they chose that virus--because most people carry it.  The issue was not that the children carried it, but how many antibodies to it they had.

February 6, 2009 12:52 PM

About Shannon LC Cate

Shannon LC Cate, PhD is a lesbian housewife and work-from-home mother of two girls via domestic, open, transracial adoption. They are both under five and already too brilliant and beautiful for their own good. Shannon lives, writes and assembles tricycles in Chicago, Illinois.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage