Strollerderby

Kids: Bringers or Destroyers of Marital Happiness?

Posted by Kate Tuttle

So, does a child bring greater love, happiness, and intimacy to his or her parents, or is having children instead a marital challenge only the strongest can endure? According to several new studies (discussed in a recent New York Times health column) marital happiness declines when children are born, and stays low until they grow up and leave the house. Empty nesters, whom popular media and self-help books would teach us to pity, turn out to be among the happiest of all married people! 

As with so many "groundbreaking" new research results, this one leaves me surprised anyone is surprised. Of course having children is backbreaking, infuriating, heartbreaking and absolutely incompatible with so many of the things that make life truly fun (spontaneous travel, sex and drinking, for instance!).  On the other hand, surviving the early years of parenthood and reaching a state of satisfiction with one's adult children and spouse would seem like a slam dunk in the happiness department. The studies cited in the Times article dealt mostly with women's happiness, which they described as peaking when women hit their 60s and presumably had launched their children into the world (although with many of us now having kids into our early 40s, some of us will still be scouting colleges and paying tuition deep into our mid-sixties). Less studied was the effect of having children on men's happiness, but one study seemed to address the gender inequality so common in family life: 

The arrival of children also puts a disproportionate burden of household duties on women, a common source of marital conflict. After children, housework increases three times as much for women as for men, according to studies from the Center on Population, Gender and Social Equality at the University of Maryland.

Didn't Ann Landers famously ask people to write in and say whether or not they were glad they had had kids, and wasn't the nation shocked when a full 70% of her respondants (10,000 people!) said that if they had it to do over, they would not have had kids? Having children is hard work, folks, and while it's no surprise they put enormous pressure on our marriages while they're young, it's really kind of heartening to hear that maybe, when all these grueling years are past us, we can enjoy true marital bliss in our empty nests (if our 401Ks rebound enough by then for us to afford them!). 

 

More by this author:

Would You Toilet-Train Your Child On National TV?

Biracial Twins -- Is One "Black" and One "White"?

Death by Peanut: Epidemic or Urban Myth?

Is This Baby Obese? Aussie Mom Says No

 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Knitty said:

I wonder if happiness levels of people with children varies significantly depending on the parents' age, income, and education levels.  My husband and I waited until we were in our mid-30s, had masters degrees and were financially secure, all of which I'm sure are factors in our happiness now.  I imagine if we'd had children while we were still basically children ourselves, our feelings would be much different.  If we had to pick between paying the rent and buying diapers, I imagine we'd be miserable (although we'd never regret having her.)

As far as people being unhappy because children diminish their ability to "spontaneously travel" or whatever, I'm just baffled, although I suppose if you've been raised to thinking "it's all about me," then learning that it really, really isn't is going to be a very hard lesson.  

January 25, 2009 12:44 PM
 

JeanneSager said:

Knitty: I agree with you, sort of - I think part of it is the "readiness" factor.

I think some people can be ready when they're fairly young (not 18, mind you, eesh!), while others are better off waiting until - as you did - their mid-30s. So I wouldn't necessarily say it's age-dependent or even education-dependent. I know happy families where Mom and Dad have only high school diplomas, and miserable families where Mom has a PhD.

But having some solid footing beneath you before you start having children puts you a heckuva lot further ahead than parents who barely know themselves, not to mention each other, when they start out!

January 25, 2009 2:01 PM
 

martinsgirl said:

i agree with the previous poster, i don't believe age is as huge a factor than a solid footing in the relationship and MONEY... my husband and I waited til' our early 30's to have children. we had been together for 7 years, we are educated and

have a successful graphic design business but with the economy changing our

clients needs it is hitting us right in the pocketbook and all the stress of paying

the mortgage, buying diapers, hell, finding affordable health insurance has

definitely cut into the amount of happiness and contentment we felt before.

but i can see being happier in your marriage when the kids are out of the house

we never have time for each other and crave it badly...

January 25, 2009 3:45 PM
 

Laure68 said:

This "article" came from the NY Times health blogger, Tara Parker-Pope. In the past, she has been a terrible health reporter. (Misleading info, taking things completely out of context, etc.) I wouldn't take anything she writes about too seriously.

January 25, 2009 7:14 PM
 

leahsmom said:

@Laure68 - I totally second you on Parker-Pope.  I have heard about legitimate studies that show that young children and infants can really strain marriages - as I'm sure many parents would agree - but I take anything Parker-Pope writes with a canister of NaCl.

January 26, 2009 12:22 PM

About Kate Tuttle

I'm raising a toddler and a teenager in a leafy suburb just outside Boston. In between having kids I've been an editor and writer, most recently with the African American National Biography and the late great Africana.com.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage