Strollerderby

Adopting Kids: Nothing Like Adopting Puppies

Posted by JeanneSager

It was supposed to portray the goodness of man, the generous spirit of human beings.

But I found the outpouring of adoption offers for a child abandoned at a North Dakota fire station rather creepy. 

The Grand Forks Herald got e-mail after e-mail after reporting that a baby girl was left in a cardboard box at a Grand Forks firehouse, offers of permanent homes for the little girl.

There were parents with teenagers living at home, parents who say they're too old to have another child themselves, parents who are struggling with infertility issues. The parents themselves were doing nothing wrong. They were simply showing they have big hearts, and they were having as hard a time as any of us would at wrapping their heads around the idea of a mother abandoning her child. 

But the story of the abandoned child appeared in the Herald on Saturday. The responses started coming on Saturday. Did these people take any time to think about this? Did they consider what they were potentially getting themselves into? I'm not talking about parenting - these people were, by and large, already parents. But this is a child caught in a legal case, a child whose mother is being sought by police, a newborn left in those critical hours after childbirth when her mother could easily have been lost and confused. 

Some of these parents might already have been considering domestic adoption; in which case they might already have considered the chance of finding a child whose story was fraught with complications. I understand the desperation for parents who are struggling through the adoption system, the willingness to jump at any option.

But can't they let it sit a day? Can't they wait for Monday, when their lawyer's office opens, when they can approach the appropriate authorities rather than a newspaper? This isn't a puppy abandoned on the side of a road, who can be snatched up in a day by someone with a good reference from a vet and a bag of kibble ready and waiting. 

Image: Flickr

Related Posts:

Family Adopts Eight Siblings Separated by Foster Care

Baby Born Two Days After Mom's Death

Kid Woos Prospective Foster Parents With Letters

Desperately Seeking . . . Grandparents

Adoption Application Turned Down Due to Prospective Father's BMI


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Alice said:

I assume you already have children.  Offering love and care to an abandoned infant is the greatest gift they could give to that child.  It sounds to me they were moved by the plight of the child, sitting alone and uncared for in a hospital somewhere rather than in the arms of a loving caregiver. Many foster parents do just that.  They pick up abandoned newborns at the hospital everyday in this country and give them the care and attention they need to thrive.  Wanting a child and offering care to a child is not trying to "snatch up" a child.  I think your misread their intentions.  Chill out.

January 21, 2009 5:59 PM
 

jennifer said:

You have an interesting way of looking at stories like these, Jeanne. I'm not sure I would question the motives or timing of big-hearted folks who want to offer an abandoned child a home.

In some states (not North Dakota), fire stations are approved safe haven sites. Granted, the manner in which the child was delivered would probably still have prompted an investigation to find the parents. If the parents cannot be found and/or if other family members are not willing to take the child in, the baby will just be shuffled into child protective services. That is how it has to be done legally, but I think it is heartwarming that so many people would be willing to open their homes, if circumstances allowed it, to a child who had a bad start.

January 21, 2009 6:20 PM
 

chochomom said:

I have to agree with Alice and Jennifer, it's sad when everything is viewed in such a cynical light. A lot these people have been thinking and wanting another baby, and they've had kids before, so they know the amount of care a newborn needs.

There is still a lot of good in this world.

January 21, 2009 10:57 PM
 

Laundry and Children said:

I agree with Jeanne.  I certainly understand the instinct that makes a person want to save a child in need, but I have to wonder if all of these people who are putting in requests to adopt this child will now go and adopt some other child from the US foster care system.  There are thousands of children waiting for someplace to call home and for someone to call Mom and Dad.

I am an adoptive mother whose children came to us through Foster Care.  I also work with abused and neglected children.  I will say that the rewards are tremendous, but it adopting a child, just as deciding to have add to your family through birth, is not a decision that should be entered in to lightly.

I think sometimes it is easy to get swept up in the moment and become part of a group mentality to save a child who is in extraordinary circumstances and featured on the news, but, like Jeanne said, it is not like adopting a puppy.  Another way to look at it is this.  Would you propose marriage to a perfect stranger that you saw for 1 minute on the news?  The commitment to a child is just that important a decision.  If not more so.

January 22, 2009 7:34 AM
 

km said:

I think that "Laundry and Children" hit on an obvious problem that this story highlights: there is enormous demand for the relatively small number of infants that are abandoned or given up for adoption, but the same people who are so eager to open up their homes for a baby would never consider doing the same for an older child. I don't think the people who offered to adopt this baby are being particularly self-sacrificing--they want a baby! And who wouldn't? But if all the people who don't get the cutie are referred to CPS to enroll in the foster care system, that's probably the last you'll hear from them.

January 23, 2009 11:07 AM

About JeanneSager

Jeanne Sager is a writer who lives in upstate New York with her husband, daughter, a dog and too many cats. She refuses to believe motherhood comes with pumpkin appliqued sweaters, and she';s not ready to apologize for having only one child. She writes about raising her kid in her own hometown and the mom stuff she's not embarrassed to own at her blog, Inside Out (http://jeannesager.blogspot.com), she's contributing editor of Grand Magazine, and she's a regular essayist here on Babble

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage