Strollerderby

They Say: Cosleeping Doesn't Cause SIDS

Posted by Miriam Axel-Lute

A detailed four-year study in southwest Britain on bedsharing with infants has concluded that when known risk factors—such as alcohol, drugs, or extreme overtiredness—are excluded, cosleeping with an infant does not increase the risk of SIDS (known in Britain as "cot death").

Reactions across Britain included from relief from midwives who now feel they can stop telling parents who want to cosleep not to and enthusiasm from breastfeeding advocates, as well as caution from anti-SIDS advocates.

One point the researcher, Peter Blair of University of Bristol, made that I hadn't thought of is that since falling asleep with a kid on a sofa is quite dangerous (loose cushions, places to get wedged), there is a risk from parents who dutifully put a baby to sleep in a crib, get up to feed it on the couch, and fall asleep again by accident. The proportion of SIDS deaths occurring on a sofa has doubled in the past decade.

Meanwhile, the study has received little to no play in the American media. Local American papers are still churning out stories almost every day about rising rates of "cosleeping deaths," with few making the distinction between risky behaviors and cosleeping itself, or if they do, burying it under sensational headlines and leads. One paper even wrote "the problem, known as 'co-sleeping' or 'parent rollover.' " At least this appears to have been edited online since I first saw it.

Here's hoping some sense will wend its way across the pond.

  Photo by davef3138, via Flickr.

Related Posts:

More by this author:

 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

gpgirl said:

I had to laugh a little at the comment "when known risk factors—such as alcohol, drugs, or extreme overtiredness—are excluded". How can you exclude extreme overtiredness? Who is not extremely overtired with an infant?

Otherwise, I do agree with you that the news media can twist data to suit what they want to say.

December 2, 2008 2:17 PM
 

Miriam Axel-Lute said:

You make a good point. They do quantify "extreme" as less than four hours of sleep the night before, so at least it's measurable.

For me it's a little chicken and egg: If I didn't cosleep, I'd be too tired to safely cosleep.

December 2, 2008 3:05 PM
 

mamanoomnom said:

I find it a little funny that the picture used for this article shows some pretty questionable cosleeping behavior: -baby is laying on its tummy

-baby is laying on top of a sleeping adult whose chest that baby could slip off of

-there is a blanket pulled up close to the baby's head and a pillow right in front of the baby's face

-and the adult is a man (he is presumably not the baby's mother)

Pro-cosleeping pediatricians would argue that it is pretty important that the mother, and only the mother, sleep right next to the baby. They feel that a mother's instincts are better than anyone else's when it comes to her baby and she is least likely to roll over on the baby or otherwise harm it in her sleep.

And the rest of what I noticed...well it's just common sense. No suffocation or falling hazards should be part of the baby's sleeping environment.

It's good to see research showing that cosleeping can be safe, but as always it has to be explained that you have to take safety precautions, regardless of whether you cosleep or not.

December 2, 2008 5:44 PM
 

lovin' sleep said:

I have a 3 1/2 yr old daughter who still sleeps with us.  I have only been up in the middle of the night with her 4 times in her life time.  We sleep great, we have a "side car" bed, with rails, that bumps up to my bed.  To me, sleep is one of the most important things in life - good, quality sleep makes everyone happy. I contribute this to my husband and I's decision to co-sleep.

December 2, 2008 6:02 PM
 

Treespeed said:

mamanoomnom,

Oh that's rich, only a mother has the instincts to co-sleep?

LOL!

How very womyn's studies 101.

Off to the couch with Dad.

December 2, 2008 6:42 PM
 

gpgirl said:

mamanoomnom, if only the mother can sleep with the baby, what happens to dad? Does he have to go sleep on the couch?

December 2, 2008 7:12 PM
 

Larissa said:

Actually, mother's sleep cycles have been shown to synchronize with the infants.  I don't know if a fathers WOULD if he were needed by the infant (for feeding, etc.).  I think it is more neurophysiology than sexism that makes the safety recommendation that the baby co-sleeps safest with mums.

December 2, 2008 9:11 PM
 

mamanomnom said:

To clarify: the mother sleeps in the middle, so that she's between the infant and the father. Daddy isn't banished to the couch.

As for the mother having better instincts, check out the info on cosleeping in Dr. Mom's Guide to Breastfeeding. Basically she states that the mother is more aware of the baby and more attuned to it, thus she's less likely to forget the baby is there and roll over on it or pull a blanket over it.

December 3, 2008 1:15 AM
 

maeby said:

mamanomnom: confirmed my beliefs all along! It totally makes sense to me.

December 3, 2008 11:32 AM
 

anavoog said:

that's a bunch of crap that it's not safe for men to sleep next to their babies because they lack the instinct.

how horribly sexist and demeaning to men.

my husband slept next to our daughter just the same as me.

of COURSE he has instincts, as well, and it's ignorant and sexist to declare otherwise.

December 3, 2008 2:02 PM
 

Treespeed said:

You know us clueless fathers, always forgetting we have a baby sleeping next to us.

It's always amazing to me that in regards to childrearing that so many misandrist myths persist.

Just because Dr. Mom is peddling psuedoscience, doesn't stop it being psuedoscience.

December 3, 2008 4:21 PM

About Miriam Axel-Lute

Miriam Axel-Lute is a freelance writer, editor, poet, and urban planning junkie. She lives, works, and gardens in Albany, NY, with her two partners and daughter.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage