Strollerderby

Disney Pulls Hannah Montana Diabetes Episode

Posted by Brett Singer

Disney pulled the first episode of the new season of Hannah Montana after parents complained. The episode discussed diabetes. Hannah Montana has managed to piss off a bunch of parents. But it wasn't with her music.

Apparently the Disney Channel pulled what was going to be the first episode of the new season because some parents who saw it early complained. "The episode, titled 'No Sugar, Sugar,' finds Hannah’s friend Oliver learning he has diabetes and was intended to teach audiences that the disease is one that can be managed." Some parents, "had concerns about how the disease was portrayed," although the New York Times article I saw doesn't mention any specifics. The title does sound a little bit jokey. (Maybe they were trying to revive Miley's dad's series "Doc".) But come on -- what did they do? Put a Snickers on a fishing pole and dangle it in front of a diabetic character?

One thing that "Seinfeld" was supposed to have taught us is that the "very special episode" is usually a bad idea. I'm not saying that it's not a nice thing for a show watched by zillions of tweens to actually try to teach a lesson now and then. But usually it comes across as forced. (David Spade, before he was famous, used to do a funny stand-up routine about "a very special episode of 'Family Ties'" where Alex is caught masturbating. "Aw Mal, can't you knock?") I've never seen Hannah Montana, but my guess is that people don't usually watch the show looking for issues-oriented television.

For that, everybody knows you should watch the new "90210". I mean, really.

Interesting twist: Apparently Nick Jonas is diabetic, and Miley Ray Hannah Montana Stewart Cyrus Lipschitz used to wear some sort of "diabetic dog tag" in support of the Jonas Brother that she either was or wasn't dating. (I can't remember and don't care enough to look it up.)

I do think it’s a little weird when a network yanks a show – in this case before it even officially aired – based on the complaints of a few people. How bad could it have been? I remember an episode of "The Brady Bunch" where Mike says to Carol, "If I ever caught one of my sons playing with dolls, I'd send him to a psychiatrist." (Cue laugh track.) My mother heard the line and asked me if I thought that was an OK thing to say, especially since I played with action figures, which are very doll-like. So maybe a better move is to watch the show with your kids and talk to them about anything you find objectionable.

Or just shut the TV off. But let's not get too crazy.

Source: NYTimes, EntertainmentWise

Image: EntertainmentWise

Read more:

Morning News: Public Schools? Hannah Montana? Michelle O's Big Decisions

Malia and Sasha, Meet Miley

Woman changes her name to Cutout Dissection.com

Matt Lauer Talks To Sarah Palin In The Kitchen

Smokers No Longer Allowed Foster Children

About Ann Nixon Cooper



+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

leahsmom said:

People with type I diabetes can eat pretty much anything - sugar should be limited - just like with any healthy diet, but we can eat it! Welcome to my top pet peeve about misunderstandings of the disease - people who tell me I can't eat things because I'm diabetic, take food away from me that was ON MY PLATE because I'm diabetic (I'm a sucker for a good brownie) or tell me, in front of my child, "well, it's not my fault if you die because you ate that!"

I've had this sucker for 23 years, I eat a brownie occasionally, and I'm doing just fine, thanks, people!  

So I'd be pissed if this show had all that misinformation, too.

November 13, 2008 10:06 AM
 

Brett Singer said:

Good point. That brings up another question of course - how did they make those mistakes if they "contacted experts" which the article says they did? Of course, one person's expert is another person's moron...

November 13, 2008 1:04 PM
 

tim said:

The Disney channel offers nothing positive to their audiences. Their primary function is teaching consumerism to children, with sugar cereal and other junk foods amongst their primary advertisers. They, of course, know that they can run an episode about diabetes and still promote unhealthy diets but I'd be interested to know more about their reasoning behind pulling the episode. Perhaps they were unable to work in their questionable position on sex roles for girls while scorning the kid with the sugar addiction?

November 17, 2008 11:28 AM

About Brett Singer

Brett Singer is a writer and father living in Manhattan with his wonderful wife and two terrific sons (referred to here as Thing 1 and Thing 2). He writes about music for the Boston Phoenix, parenting for Babble and daddytips.com, and other topics for anyone else who will have him.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage