Strollerderby

Do Kids Really Need Tread Mills?

Posted by Shannon LC Cate

The new focus in our culture on childhood obesity has led to some interesting shifts in childhood itself, the most recent of which is club memberships for kids.  The Chicago Tribune reports that:

"Fitness club memberships for youths age 6 to 17 have more than doubled in the past two decades, rising from 1.3 million in 1987 to 3.9 million in 2007. More than 1.3 million of those memberships were for children 6 to 11, according to the International Health, Racquet and Sportsclub Association."

One might think new concerns about sedentary kids would hurt the video game industry.  Not so!  They are on the edge of the professional kid fitness trend themselves, with products like Wii Fit, Nintendo's interactive exercise program and Gamercize, that makes video games work only when the player is moving.

The Tribune suggests that:

"Outdoor games such as hopscotch and tag that kept Baby Boomers fit when they were kids have largely fallen by the wayside. With busy family schedules and concerns about neighborhood safety weighing on parents' minds, many youths are more likely to play video games inside than ride a bike outside."

But I'm not 100% convinced.  At $69-$125 per month for membership to a youth gym, I have to wonder how many parents can afford to budget the expense these days when there are perfectly good, free and reasonably safe playgrounds in most neighborhoods (certainly in neighborhoods in which residents can afford to contemplate kiddie gym memberships).  I also have a hard time reconciling this "trend" with what we are told is another trend in bike-riding in times of expensive gasoline and concern about global warming.

What do you think?  Does your kid go to a youth health club?  Would you consider such a membership for a young child?  What other (better?) ways do you get your kids moving?

Related Post:

When Times Call for Frugality...What Goes?


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Beth said:

I guess if I had the money, I could see it as a time-saver to help the PARENT get to the gym: the child could take karate or something while the parent works out? (Are they counting Y memberships?) I would think most of what I think of as gym equipment would be pretty dangerous for kids under 12, though, aside from not being out in the sunshine.

October 25, 2008 7:57 PM
 

Skye said:

Hey, it gets even wackier - we pay $65 per month for a "gym" membership for our ONE year old.  Sounds ridiculous to get a gym membership for a one year old until you realize that it's basically just a big playroom with lots of different kinds of equipment, and the weekly "gym class" is some free play (he loves the mini basketball hoop), some songs as a group, and some 1-on-1 activities with the teachers and/or adult who brought the kid to class.

Because he's enrolled in class, he can also go to other free play sessions once or more during the week.  His grandmother who takes care of him wanted them both to have some variety, and a place to play when it gets too cold for the park.  Right now it's not cold, so often he does both in one day.  He started walking at 9 months, he's extremely active, he's bored with everything in the house, so honestly $65 doesn't seem like a lot to me for help in wearing him out! ;)

It's really just a preschool motor skills class even though the rhetoric the people who own it use is very much about fitness, etc.  They tell his grandma all about how what they're doing is good for certain muscle groups and I just roll my eyes.  All I care about is if he's playing and having fun and safe.

October 26, 2008 12:35 AM
 

Lori said:

I have a 10 year old son and a 9 year old daughter.  

We limit video games to weekends and TV to one hour per day.  

We get outside as often as possible.  We walk to and from school.  We play good old fashioned kid games, kick the can, four square, shooting baskets etc.  I once bought hoola hoops for a quarter each at a garage sale, best money I have ever spent.  Do you know how creative a kid can be with a hoola hoop?

We nurture their interest.  For my son it is basketball, football and baseball.  For my DD it is gymnastics and jump rope.  

We bought our house for several reasons, including a huge back yard and a huge rec room.  When my kids were little they rode their trykes in the rec room.  It is now home to a ping pong table.

The only reason I would consider a gym membership would be for an indoor basketball hoop and the pool.  

Probably most important is unplugging kids and letting them entertain themselves.   Kids tend to expand a lot of energy when we encourage them to find creative ways to spend their time.  

October 27, 2008 12:53 AM
 

leahsmom said:

I just remember being the kid who never wanted to get exercise - as I've gotten older, I do it now because I'd rather not drop dead from a heart attack tomorrow, but until I was about 21, you just couldn't get me moving.  We didn't have cable, and I never owned a video game, so we can't blame that industry - it was just how I was. I hated to be sweaty and dirty, and I didn't like being out of breath, it felt like something was wrong. I didn't like being in the hot sun or in cold and wet - I was just a finicky little child.  There was absolutely nothing my parents could do! They signed me up for sports - I dropped out. They'd drive me to the Y and I'd just sit and wait for them to come back. My mom would encourage me to go on walks with her - I'd beg off to dive into my next book.  I'm sure that kids are indeed less active these days than they used to be, and that some kids might be encouraged out of it. But I also bet some kids are just like I was - and there's not much you can do with a little pain in the a$$ like me!

October 27, 2008 9:01 AM
 

Elise said:

I would pay for a gym membership for a child if it was the only way they could have regular access to playing sports or doing activities with other kids. For example, if I lived in an area where there were no other kids the same age or the nearest playground/schoolyard was more than a mile away. Why I would be living in such a situation with a child I don't know, but it could happen.

In addition, I would follow some of the same guidelines that my mom had (which I totally didn't resent at the time, it was just the way life was.)

If you want to go somewhere, you walk or ride your bike.

Helping with housework and outside chores is mandatory.

You clean your own room and do your own laundry.

Want to take swimming, dance, gymnastics or martial arts - no problem. If it's a nice day, you can walk or ride your bike to them.

Bored? Go outside and don't come back until it's time for dinner.

To this day, I hate working out but am willing to walk a mile or two to meet a friend for coffee.

October 27, 2008 2:50 PM

About Shannon LC Cate

Shannon LC Cate, PhD is a lesbian housewife and work-from-home mother of two girls via domestic, open, transracial adoption. They are both under five and already too brilliant and beautiful for their own good. Shannon lives, writes and assembles tricycles in Chicago, Illinois.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage