Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Q: Is It Harder to Raise Boys or Girls?

Posted by Madeline Holler

A: That depends, according to this Parenting report on CNN.com.

Now, what it depends on is (1) the particular child-rearing area you're considering and (2) the age of the child. The upshot is, boys are harder in the beginning. Girls are harder in the end. I don't know, gender-behavior crap still kind of gets on my nerves. Like, there's no mention of the child as an individual -- I know difficult boys AND girls -- and there is also only passing mention of the whole "nurture" rather than "nature" side of a child's development.

Here's a summary. You can go here for details.

Discipline -- boys are harder

Physical safety -- boys are harder

Communication -- first boys are harder, then girls

Self-esteem -- girls

School -- boys 

You know, I can accept that there are gender differences in the pace or sequence of brain development. But what I hate this the idea "girls are better communicators." Maybe at an earlier age, but until the end of time? Not even. Same with boys have an easier time with spatial relations (or better hearing, earlier in life, as the article says). That doesn't mean girls don't come fully around later and go head-to-head with the boys in pre-engineering classes. 

The other thing is calling one gender "harder" or "easier," even broken down into categories. A mom reported this stuff. Some men (or women) might think dealing with kids jumping off a coffee table is a much easier prospect than sharing feelings or dealing with body image.

Of course, I say this as a girl who was raised with girls and is raising girls. What do you think? Are boys harder?

 

Photo: CNN.com


Comments

 

Janice said:

No, boys are easy. But the emotional life of a girl is draining, dramatic and exhausting.

June 19, 2008 1:36 PM
 

Mom2Two said:

The discipline and physical safety has definitely been harder with my boy.  My brother put my mom through the wringer with discipline stuff.  But I think girl's social issues have a bigger impact, emotionally.  I'm drained phsically at the end of the day with my son.  I'm drained emotionally at the end of a day with a tween girl.

June 19, 2008 1:51 PM
 

Adam said:

I hope the answer is boys are easier...I'm about to have my first :)  I've imagined it being harder to raise a girl, but I think your right...it just depends on the kid.

Adam

<a href='http://adam-finch.eachday.com'>http://adam-finch.eachday.com</a>

June 19, 2008 2:11 PM
 

Brett Singer said:

Boys couldn't possibly be harder. I have boys. So I know.

June 19, 2008 5:02 PM
 

martinsgirl said:

of course they are generalizing... having one of each, my girl turning 6 next week and my boy just shy of 2, my sweet darling of a girl has been difficult since the day she came into this world, not because she's rotten by any means but intense, spirited, and busy with a capital B, so difficult with discipline, while my son is mellow,big personality with a few drama moments, but

sooo toned down than his big sis and does just what i ask. i think it's more they're individual personalities than anything else. as a generalization i understand where

they are coming from, it's what you hear more most parents, it's just not my

story.

June 19, 2008 7:24 PM
 

Sherry said:

I have one of each and totally agree with your little summary.

June 19, 2008 11:31 PM
 

Maureen said:

I have one of each and they are usually difficult on different days:)  That way I can fully appreciate the good behavior of one, while the other is driving me freakin nuts.  

My daughter is much more emotional, but my boy has to touch and climb on EVERYTHING.  

June 20, 2008 12:38 AM
 

Manjari said:

I have boy/girl twins. They are only 19 months old. So far my son is definitely the one that runs all over the house and climbs on stuff. He wears me out a bit more physically. My daughter is pretty easy going most of the time, but she won't play independently long enough to let me enjoy my coffee. She always wants to be in my lap.

June 20, 2008 6:57 AM
 

Celina said:

I think it what you as a parent find difficult. There are some things that are just going to bother you more. Dirt on other's clothing doesn't bother me. Snot/peanut butter/gook on MY clothes bothers me. So my children getting filthy is fine. I find the emotional storms much more challenging. I've seen fine examples of them from both genders. I've seen boys do "mean girl" stuff. I've seen girls launch physical attacks.

I think each age has its challenges. I'm worried about the early teen stuff.

June 20, 2008 1:38 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage