Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

They Say: The Five-Second Rule is B.S.

Posted by Jen Chaney

I have based my life on certain principles. That hard work always pays off, in ways sometimes tangible and sometimes intangible. That you should treat others with the same respect you expect from them. And that as long as something has been on the floor for five seconds or less, it's not really dirty.

Now this article in the Sydney Morning Herald -- courtesy of MomLogic -- says that's not true, although in Australia, they call it the three-second rule. Apparently the Aussies don't have the patience (or low hygiene standards) to take things to the five-second level. 

Anyhoo, whether you go by three seconds or five, it appears that some serious bacteria can grow on food that's fallen on the floor, even if it's only been there for a nanosecond. If you then proceed to hand that cracker or apple slice to your kid, well, you're just giving him a big 'ol heap of potential food poisoning.

Do you buy this? Or, like me, do you find that it violates every notion you hold dear?

Photo Credit: The Times and Democrat 

 


Comments

 

martinsgirl said:

sorry for not having specifics, but 2 american college students tested

the five second rule a couple years back and found that if it is a soft object

like cheese, an apple slice, etc. that indeed bacteria should up immediately,

but with a hard object like a m&m's bacteria was apparent up even later than 5 seconds. i still wouldn't eat it or give it to my child, call me crazy. : )

April 30, 2008 7:19 PM
 

MissB said:

Whatever.  In my house we have the, "If you can find it and put it in your mouth before mom sees you you're golden." rule.  My children will have immune systems of iron!

April 30, 2008 8:29 PM
 

Grace said:

They tested this on Mythbusters about a year ago.  It doesn't matter how long it's been on the floor, it depends on how clean or dirty the floor is.  And in case anyone is interested, the dirtiest area they tested was the kitchen floor- far worse than the bathroom floor AND the toilet seat.

April 30, 2008 8:43 PM
 

LogicalMama said:

I'm with MissB!

Christ, as a little kid, I'd use a public bathroom, not wash my hands and then eat with my fingers!!!!!!!!!!

April 30, 2008 10:37 PM
 

kelly lou said:

i also stand by the old saying'god made dirt and dirt don't hurt' it's seems to work-26yrs and i'm still alive!

April 30, 2008 11:29 PM
 

Kim said:

I used to worry about my kid's food being clean. Then one day I saw him try putting a dead bird in his mouth. I FREAKED and called poison control and they said not to worry. So that kind of puts the occasional household dirt into perspective for me!

May 1, 2008 9:08 AM
 

maeby said:

as a child i CONSTANTLY ate crap off the floor, never washed my hands for anything, and played in dirt all day. I was a filthy child. I have NEVER had a fever, the flu, thrown up (i cant remember before age 3 though) or any other ailments. Well....once i got a cold for a day in a half. I THOUGHT I WAS GOING TO DIE.

Anyway my immune system is made of the gods.

unless its full of dirt and dust bunnies, i say let the children eat the crap off the floor!

May 1, 2008 9:43 AM
 

anonymous2 said:

I've never believed in the 5-second rule.  The second something hits any kind of dirty surface, it's dirty.  That said, I KNOW my floor is clean, so I have no problem letting my daughter eat anything off of it.  If we're in a public place, different story.  That said, I have to agree with maeby that unless the child has some sort of immunodeficiency issue, a little dirt won't kill them.  Kids need to be exposed to some germs to build up their little immune systems.  

May 1, 2008 11:13 AM
 

DCMama said:

If you have a dog there is no 2 second or 5 second rule. If it hits the floor in our house its dog food.  Now, about the times the toddler offers food to the dog and then snatches it back out of the dogs mouth and into his own, I'm not sure what rule to apply there.

May 1, 2008 12:56 PM

About Jen Chaney

Jen Chaney is the movies editor and a DVD columnist for washingtonpost.com. Her byline has appeared in The Washington Post, People magazine, USA Today and the Utne Reader as well as various other newspapers around the country. She is the mother of a one-year-old boy, who has not yet learned the word Xanadu. But he will. Trust us, he will.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage