Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Babble Talk: Is Child Bribery Bad?

Posted by Jen Chaney

In this week's Bad Parent installment, Keri Fisher raises an important question: Is it bad to bribe our kids to encourage good behavior? As Keri's essay points out, everyone has an opinion on the subject. Some think that a little harmless quid pro quo -- "If you eat your vegetables, you get some ice cream" -- is no big deal. Others, like Kathy Waugh, see it as evidence of our "mercenary, gimme-gimme-gimme culture." And then there's Keri's mom, who believes that rewarding a child for doing what he should have done in the first place is akin to ceding control to the little bugger.

Personally, I take a nuanced view of the whole thing: I think the appropriateness of the "bribery" depends on the behavior sought, the reward offered and the frequency of such incentives. The examples Keri cops to -- refusing to give her autistic nephew his favorite food if he hits, promising hermit crabs to her niece if she completes her math homework and letting her son and his cousins read board books at the kitchen table -- strike me as fairly harmless. Of the three I just mentioned, the herbit crab one veers closest to dodgy territory because it involves the giving of a gift for doing something relatively minor, a possible infraction of the "gimme-gimme-gimme" code.

But if you're trying to teach an autistic child not to do something bad, I think it's perfectly reasonable to withhold french fries to drive the point home. And letting the kids read board books at the table in exchange for a peaceful meal? That's understandable. To me, the far worse parental crime is to proffer a bribe without following through. If we tell little Brady he can't watch "Spongebob" if he slams his bedroom door and he still bangs it shut, then that kid better not wind up flipping on Nickelodeon twenty minutes later. But I know a few parents who, out of exhaustion or just general lack of discipline, will allow him to do just that. And that's the point when parents start to lose their authority.

Lastly, I'd just like to point out that Keri -- who lives with her sister and her family -- lives in a home with seven children. SEVEN. Keri, if you need to resort to bribery, honey, you go ahead. If I were you, I'd be looking at bribery, blackmail, extortion and grand larceny if that's what it took. 


Comments

 

Mike Adamick (Cry It Out!) said:

With seven kids, Keri can resort to blackmail, extortion, whatever. I'm a fan of the small bribe -- eat your veggies and you can have some mango -- so long as its antithesis is present and enforced as well. "Do that one more that and you get a timeout."

April 4, 2008 10:04 AM
 

Mom2Two said:

I bribe myself to exercise.  I just call it an incentive instead.

I just blogged about this the other day because I bribed my son with a piece of chocolate so I could clip his toenails.  It was totally worth not getting kicked in the face.

I have a friend who bribes her son at every meal with dessert.  Consequently, he has come to expect it and will not eat without the promise of a treat.  And Baltimore City has started to pay its students for good grades, which I am adamantly against.

But a small bribe every once in awhile?  Not a problem.

April 4, 2008 10:33 AM
 

g8grl said:

I used to bribe my little girl with a skittles when she went pee pee in the potty.  Worked for awhile, then she decided a skittles wasn't enough (right about when her baby brother was born, typical).  Anyway, if I could think of a better bribe that would bring around the right results, I would do it.  Currently, we're just waiting for her to decide when she wants to do it.

April 4, 2008 12:14 PM
 

km said:

My 5 y/o son has a "chore chart" that he does on school days.  If he does it every day for a month, he gets to pick a surprise (a new action figure, a trip to the movies or arcade, etc.).  Some of the chores are kinda easy (Get dressed, eat breakfast, brush teeth), some are a little tougher (set table, clear table, put away his laundry).  I have them divided into morning, after-school and before bed chores, so it doesn't feel so overwhelming to him (there are about 12-14 chores total).  

He likes to check off each chore as he finishes it, and if he's ever feeling lazy, I just remind him that he won't get his surprise at the end of the month.  It's still bribery, but I kind of see it as a tool for teaching him what is expected of him on a daily basis.  I had toyed with the idea of giving him a treat at the end of each day (dessert maybe), but decided he needed something a little more long-term to focus on, as he does tend to be slightly unappreciative of what he has.

NB:  I'm really not usually so hyper-organized.  If you saw my house, you'd see I could definitely benefit from a chore chart of my own.  :)

April 5, 2008 12:03 AM

About Jen Chaney

Jen Chaney is the movies editor and a DVD columnist for washingtonpost.com. Her byline has appeared in The Washington Post, People magazine, USA Today and the Utne Reader as well as various other newspapers around the country. She is the mother of a one-year-old boy, who has not yet learned the word Xanadu. But he will. Trust us, he will.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage