Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Weekly Check-Up: Skittles and Wellness

Posted by Kelly Mills
skittles offender

Maybe you heard this story: An honor student at a Connecticut middle school got busted for buying Skittles on school grounds. He was stripped of his job as class president, banned from attending an honors student dinner, and suspended for three days, later communted to one day (maybe for good behavior, like he ate an apple in front of the principal or something.) The latest breaking news is that he was cleared of the charges and had his records cleaned up. The student says he didn't know candy was contraband, though he did notice the student dealing in sweets was acting all furtive. Candy is forbidden as part of the school's wellness policy.

Ah, back in my day the schools themselves sold candy to kids at a snack bar, and I'm super glad that's a thing of the past. But this level of punishment is ridiculous, unless the Skittles came with an accompanying bag of weed and a switchblade. On the one hand, this must be an extreme example of a school taking a no-sugar policy to the nth degree, and I'd hate for folks to rise up and cry foul when the food industry and soda lobbies are working hard to push crap-food on our kids by sweetening the deal for schools (sponsoring football fields, generating revenue through soda machines, etc.) However, it does raise one point I think is key: Keep perspective on junk food so we don't lapse into hysteria. Sugar and candy and cupcakes (mmmm) are not going to make anyone "unwell" unless they are consumed in mass quanities very regularly (or you have some medical reason for not being able to eat them, of course.) We don't have to allow them to be pimped in schools, but we also don'thave to make candy a crime. Teaching our children the value of moderation and balance is far better.


Comments

 

MamaS said:

My friend works at a "no-candy" middle school.  "Candy" includes soda pop.  While she's not necessarily all for the ban...she likes an occasional lump of sugar herself, she's explained that many kids (unfortunately) would bring a "lunch" to school that consisted of a bag of gummy bears and a gallon of mountain dew.  Doesnt' make for very efficient learning.  I think it's okay to put limits on this kind of thing...completely banning it is going a little far.  For intance in my high school--a mere 15 years ago--they shut off the junk food and soda vending machines during lunch hour.  Were we pissed??? Yes! Do I understand now why they did it?  Yes!  Again, limits are fine but criminalizing it is not.

March 13, 2008 3:57 PM
 

LogicalMama said:

I am all for healthy lunches. As a matter of fact, my child's typical lunch has two vegies and a healthy protein. That being said, one day, I put two small squares of organic chocolate in his lunch (for two reasons: 1- I know other children in his class had hershey's kisses and, 2- the SCHOOL NEWSLETTER suggested it for Valentine's day!) Well, all hell broke loose. Thank goodness they didn't confiscate the organic chocolate (that stuff is expensive!), but they wouldn't let him eat it.

I found out that it's the law based on the federal school lunch program, although some parents are saying that the law states the school can't sell it, but if it comes from home it should be OK. However, my obviously observant five year old asked me, "what is the difference between the chocolate you gave me and the chocolate cake they sell with the lunch?" Or what about the chocolate chip cookie that might have M&M's, or the brownie, or the snickerdoodles, the coffee cake?!! Whether it comes from home or is sold on the hot lunch, that form is allowed!?

And while this is an elementary school and does not have vending machines; in consideration of the higher grades that do, what is the difference between soda and Snapples or even Vitamin Water? They all have exhorbatant amounts of sugar in the form of high fructose corn syrup!

March 13, 2008 4:19 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • drool.icio.us

    The top million must-have baby products.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage