Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Go Ahead and Take Young Kids to Racy Movies

Posted by Madeline Holler

Because I have no clue what I'm doing as a parent -- and I mean that sincerely -- I am susceptible to taking parenting advice from New York Times movie writers and anybody else who tells me what I want to hear. Dangerous? Sure, but I figure, if a guy from the Times is wrecking his kids, can't I?

Today's questionable advice, which I believe has led to the opening of a tightly sealed floodgate for me: screw movie ratings, take your kid to grown-up movies. OK, I will!

He writes:

"... while I am happy (or at least willing) to take my children to the latest animated or tweener-star-driven “family” movies — with their singing chipmunks and chirpy Loch Ness Monsters — we gravitate more and more toward age- inappropriate fare, exploring the grown-up realms of PG-13 and even, sometimes, R."

His daughter is in the third grade and his son is in the sixth and they've seen it all. Or a lot of it, he bravely discloses. You know what? Good for him (actually, good for them, the kids, the family.) His son loved the international intrigue of Charlie Wilson's War and thought Sweeney Todd was just great. He doesn't think The Kite Runner, after all, a story about a close friendship, should be adults-only.

"... children, more than critics, are receptive to anything that doesn’t bore them. Mine were enchanted by “Persepolis,” for instance, which is after all the story of a rebellious young girl contending with unjust authority. It’s not so different from “The Golden Compass” (which they also liked), except that instead of taking place in a computer-generated fantasy world full of armored bears it is set in the real country of Iran, which is rendered in beautifully drawn ink-washed two-dimensional animation. “Persepolis” is also in French, but don’t let that put you off. If your children can read just-right books, surely they can read subtitles too."

One of the big trade-offs with having kids for me was cutting way down on movie-going. It's expensive when you have to budget for a babysitter, and you have to do a little more planning than in the olden days, when I could just show up and see whatever, whenever. But one thing I have been looking forward to is when the older girl gets old enough to come with me -- to movies I want to see. Hey, I guess she already is! A guy in the New York Times said so!  (Though I think I'll put There Will Be Blood in my Netflix queue, just to be safe.)

What about you? When are your kids going to be old enough to see your movies? 

 

Photo: www.ageowns.com 


Comments

 

jenny bean said:

It's not the movie content that worries me but my daughters penchant for bathroom trips.  

January 11, 2008 6:15 PM
 

chyna823 said:

It totally depends on the kid. Some kids could handle the stylized violence of Sweeney Todd, others would have nightmares for weeks. Like, when I was 5 and saw The Wizard of Oz, I was transfixed by the costumes and colors and music. But when my brother was 5, he was more fixated on the Wicked Witch and her flying monkeys, and got pretty freaked out.

January 11, 2008 8:30 PM
 

pointykitty said:

totally depends on the kid.  My 5-year-old saw Sweeney Todd and did great.  I was grateful she got to see really good musical theater for the price of a movie.  However, this is a child who, during the death scene in Charlotte's Web whispered to me "Can we have some candy when we get home?"  While some children I know were weeping all day.  Most kid's movies are such crap, I feel lucky she can handle something I like.  I consider every movie carefully.  I can't wait until she's ready for the awesome girl power of Kill Bill but that's not going to be anytime soon!  No way.

January 12, 2008 12:09 PM
 

Celina said:

  I don't know. We got "The Holy Grail" and watched it, and the ONE thing my boys talked about afterwards was ... "Why did all those girls want to be spanked?"

  So for me it is really the sexual politics I'd like to shield them from for a bit longer.

  I'm happy with "you get married and then you have a baby" thing for a while yet. Worked for my husband until, oh, still working.

January 13, 2008 5:26 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage