Strollerderby

Things Fall Apart: Bumbo Baby Seats Can Kill! (Not Really)

Posted by Karen Murphy

bumbo baby seatWhen my youngest was tiny(er) I bought him a Bumbo Baby Sitter baby seat. He had difficulty sitting because of having low tone from Down syndrome, lalalala, and the Bumbo seat was supposed to help him feel supported, learn to use different muscles, look at the world (finally! he was about a year old at this point) from a more upright position, blahdiblah. And zillions of parents buy these things and put their (way too tiny, in my opinion) babies in them too. But don't get me started on the Bumbo seat, I'll explain more about my feelings on the matter in a moment, because the important thing to relay to you in this first paragraph befre the obligatory jump is that the things have been recalled.

But wait!

See, I should probably explain my position on the Bumbo seat first. Because then all this recall stuff makes sense (plus I can mock it, which is totally why I am here, for the mocking).

Here's the thing: the seats themselves don't suck, but I think that many of the parents sticking their kds in them do. Well, not suck exactly, but are using the seat in ways for which it was not intended. When I got mine, not saying that I'm brilliant or superior or anything (except I am if I say so and look! Now it's in print!), but when I got my seat, and when I say "my" I mean my son's, I read the instructions. Which made sense. And then, putting him in the seat, I could see some flaws. He was a skinny kid, very wee for his age (still is: medical issues, hello!), and  didn't really fill the seat up all that much. Most babies would, at least more so. And in the not filling it up I could see there was a chance of him slipping out of it. Plus, not being able to actually support himself in the seat, he was sort of slumped over a bit and also in danger of falling out that way, and my biggest beef with the Bumbo seat is the parents who stick their obviously too-young and not-ready-for-it babies in it.

I put my kid's seat away until he was a little older, and then it worked pretty well. Except I always felt I needed to watch him. And, er, as convenient as it might have been to stick him whilst in the seat on a table or something (so much more convenient for me!) I resisted the temptation because, well, it didn't feel safe.

Buuuut...apparently many parents have ignored the instructions (and my intuition) that cautions against using the seat on an elevated surface, and babies are falling out of the Bumbo seat right and left. On to their heads. Which is probaby not good. 

But my favorite part of the recall is this: if you are the proud owner of one of the One Million Bumbo seats being recalled, you can contact Bumbo International, and get a free sticker. To put on the seat. (Which says: "Hey Stupid! Read the instructions dammit and use this seat as designed! Don't be an idjit!")

Seriously, 28 babies have fallen out of these seats, and 3 of them have fractured their skulls. I've been following this story for awhile, and Bumbo maintains that the seats are safe but that people are using them improperly. Which I totally believe, all of it. 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

crabmommy said:

For crying out loud! Again the twit-parents bumbling through parenthood and messing it up for the rest of us. First we have the FDA ripping cold meds because some morons mis-dosed their tots; now the dumbos with the Bumbo. Honestly, can someone just give these dufuses a class in parenting so the rest of us can use the damn seats and drug our children? Again, another safety "crisis" for our neurotic parenting culture to obsess over. Yeeesh!

October 25, 2007 4:02 PM
 

Lauren said:

My mom, who works in an ER, just took care of a baby that fell of the kitchen counter in her bumbo just about a week ago,so apparently there are 29 that have fallen. Luckily the baby was fine, but I agree - read the instructions people.

October 25, 2007 4:17 PM
 

Renee said:

Crabmommy, I'm not sure it's fair to blame the cold medicine recalls on "moron" parents.  There are documented cases where parents gave the correct dose, as advised by their pediatrician, and the child died.  For example:  www.cnn.com/.../index.html

It's just a bad risk-benefit ratio.  Even a tiny risk of overdose or death is too big when there's no evidence of benefit.

However, I do agree on the bumbo thing.  In that case, it's just common sense not being common enough.

October 25, 2007 5:12 PM
 

Renee said:

Crabmommy, I'm not sure it's fair to blame the cold medicine recalls on "moron" parents.  There are documented cases where parents gave the correct dose, as advised by their pediatrician, and the child died.  For example:  www.cnn.com/.../index.html

It's just a bad risk-benefit ratio.  Even a tiny risk of overdose or death is too big when there's no evidence of benefit.

However, I do agree on the bumbo thing.  In that case, it's just common sense not being common enough.

October 25, 2007 5:21 PM
 

Comstock said:

No one's ruined your Bumbo for you, crabmommy. No recall police will show up at your door asking for it back. You can keep putting your baby in it, at the top of the stairs, facing backwards, if you want.

October 25, 2007 7:27 PM
 

crabmommy said:

Indeed, point taken. I can use my Bumbo. And I certainly don't mean my snarkiness to extend to the case mentioned -- where a child turned out to be allergic to a cold medicine and died. But let's be clear: that is an  isolated case. And the FDA and everyone concerned have said the meds have been recalled because of "potential misuse of medications" (and not product safety) to quote the CNN piece mentioned above. My point is just -- the hysteria we live in. The culture of recalls. The terror of parents and manufacturers. It's all a bit too much for me. I realize there are risks implied with meds and bumbos and all these things. But when improper use is the major culprit, it's exasperating to see the effect on our society...and on our sanity. (Ok, I mean, MY sanity).

October 25, 2007 11:19 PM
 

JMom said:

"dumbos with the Bumbo" mwahahaha that's a good one :)

October 26, 2007 1:22 AM
 

Amy said:

I hear that they're going to recall all cars next.  Apparently people have been hitting stationary objects and even OTHER CARS!  And it clearly states in the instructions that you should avoid hitting anything that isn't a bug with your car.  So, in order for everyone to be safe, they're going to recall all the cars.  They're going to stop selling them, and anyone who has a car already is going to get four big stickers that say "Don't hit me!" - one for each side.

After all, think of the chillllllddrrrruuuuunnnnn....

October 26, 2007 8:55 AM
 

bombaygirl said:

Actually, its not a true recall.  You just send away for a more obvious sticker which you then have to put on the bumbo, which state (probably in bolder print?!) that this item should not be placed on tables, etc.  Still stupid.

October 26, 2007 3:56 PM
 

bombaygirl said:

oh...but you already said that.  Sorry!

October 26, 2007 3:57 PM
 

arirang said:

isn't it common sense NOT to put the damn thing on a table w/your kid in it and turn your back for a split second?

of course it doesn't help when your doctor suggests that you feed your kid in a bumbo seat or bouncer chair etc. by placing either on the TABLE so your kid can eat at your eye level. yeah I got that piece of advice. I ignored it, as the suggestion I start him on cereal at 4 months.

it never occurs to anyone to actually eat/feed your kid at THEIR eye level.

October 26, 2007 11:35 PM
 

Sherry said:

I agree with the point crabmommy was making.  Many of these situations are due to ignorance or neglect on the part of the user - not reading the directions, not following the directions even if you read them,  not paying attention , etc.  User stupidity does not mean the product needs to be changed or removed from the market.  Is a new sticker going to suddenly make an idiot smarter.  Very doubtful.  

October 27, 2007 12:00 AM
 

katy said:

Crabmommy, I have to back up Renee. The cold medicines ban wasn't so much because of dumb parents, it was because that stuff is basically snakeoil. The FDA is supposed to make sure our medicines' benefit outweigh their risk, and when there's no benefit, it's pretty clear that no amount of risk is ok. I don't always agree with the FDA, but i think they got it right this time.

Now the Bumbos...that's another story.

October 28, 2007 4:21 PM
 

Dan Keeney said:

I am a representative of the manufacturer and I just want to encourage anyone intersted in learning more about the SAFE use of the Bumbo Baby Seat to visit www.bumbosafety.com. Our online survey has found that 14 percent of Bumbo parents never noticed the warning label on the product (!) and 12 percent didn't know their kid could get out of the seat (it's in the warning and instructions). So we are redoubling our efforts to get the word out and also cleaning up some of the vague language and confusing photos in our own materials. We want to prevent future injuries. Period.

October 31, 2007 7:57 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage