Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Sleeping Babies: In Strict Silence or Normal Household Noises?

Posted by Karen Murphy

baby sleeping plaqueWith the plethora of cutesy "Shh! Baby is sleeping!" door hanger signs that abound I can guess which of two camps most parents likely fall in, but apparently there's some debate about how to treat your sleeping baby:

Camp #1: Do anything and everything possible to ensure Baby, once asleep, remains asleep. Tiptoeing and whispering is mandatory. Any errant sound, and I mean any sound, can disrupt what has become your only respite from the incessant demands of your tiny dictator.

Camp #2: You already have (insert number here) kids, what's one more? He'll sleep when he's good and tired.

While the article I'm citing makes some good points (Camp #2 may be a necessity if daycare is involved, for example, and of course balance is nearly always advised), I'm not sure that the suggestion that a child can be conditioned to join one camp or the other is all that valid. I think there are some perhaps genetic and preferential factors to be considered. My older son had silence but can and does sleep through anything. My younger daughter would only sleep, until she was almost four, if I was holding her. Ugh. Now, she too sleeps through anything.

So is the need for Camp #1 derived from desperate sleep-deprived parents? Can you truly make your child join Camp #2? What camp do you fall in?



Comments

 

RachelZ said:

Normal household noises here.  If my kid can sleep at the finish line of an Ironman triathlon, a few banging cupboard doors and the washing machine aren't going to bother her.  I can't imagine having to tiptoe around all the time.  The kid needs to conform to the ways of the house more than the house needs to conform to the kid.

July 26, 2007 11:43 AM
 

HDCS said:

I agree with Rachel. Though depending on how cranky I am and how unstable the baby is I tend to vacillate at times between the two. And sometimes the baby is a mystery. He wakes up screaming from the front door opening but he sleeps through the 4th of July illegal fireworks shows from sundown to 2 am(!!!). I'm pretty sure there were some M80's in our drunken neighbors arsenals even. And not a peep. Baffling.

July 26, 2007 12:51 PM
 

jenseju said:

Our toddler's bedroom is right off the living room, and she's a very good sleeper who snoozes through Jack Bauer's munitions extravaganzas, a dog nicknamed Miss Barksalot, and my earnest renditions of Heart while doing dishes. Life's good. But she's been at daycare every weekday since she was 7 weeks old, which I'm sure helps quite a bit. And we're just lucky, too.

July 26, 2007 1:25 PM
 

chyna823 said:

I think a lot of it is just who the kid is though--my oldest used to wake up to any noise. There were nights when we were almost afraid to pull out a Kleenex for fear that the "whiff" sound would wake her! She was like that immediately after she was born, even in our hospital room. (Thankfully, she's outgrown that.)

My youngest? Sleeps like she's in a coma. From day one, she sacks out and sleeps through anything.

I also think there's the issue of what happens if they do wake up at night--my oldest has a much harder time falling back to sleep (like me) whereas my youngest just rolls over and nods back off (like her dad).

July 26, 2007 3:47 PM
 

Jane said:

omg I'm so neurotic about this one.  I'm a total noise nazi. My house has to be silent after the kids go to sleep, except anything that's white noise-like, e.g. dishwasher, air conditioner, etc.

July 26, 2007 4:07 PM
 

Anne Glamore said:

All can sleep through anything now.  When the twins were small, we'd drive them around in the car to kill time, and now (they're almost 9) they can't stay awake more than 30 minutes in a moving car.  I hope the driver's license test only lasts 29 minutes.

July 26, 2007 5:09 PM
 

katy said:

I used to be in Camp #2. Ah, how smug I was...I thought it was the kid conforming to the way of the house, but little did I know, the house and kid just happened to be in sync. Then kid2 came along, and like no amount of conditioning will make her a heavy sleeper. so now I'm with Jane.

July 26, 2007 6:18 PM
 

Hanmee said:

I think if you're desperately sleep-deprived, you do whatever you need to to keep your kid asleep. I don't have a problem with that, especially during those first 2 months.

We operated on the "normal" household noise standard for daytime sleeping and mostly quiet for nighttime.

July 27, 2007 9:17 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage