Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Playing With Your Kids May Not Be Good For Them

Posted by Patti

Parenting philosophy is a lot like fashion: if you wait long enough, everything comes back into style. Looks like our friend Christie Mellor was on the cutting edge of a trend that might emerge from latest reseach indicating that playing with your kids is not only not the natural order of things, but it might not even be very good for them. Which means it could very well be that my exasperated pleas to "go play. With anything. With my makeup. In my wedding dress. I don't care, just GO AWAY" mean I'm doing exactly what nature intended.

One problem with the whole "play with your kids" directive, it seems, is that parents feel guilty if they aren't really into it. And of course, guilty parents are crappy ones, because getting back to biological basics doesn't mean shaking off centuries of accumulated pop-psychology wisdom. And another problem is that kids raised with the modern idea that they need to be played with by their caregivers grow up spoiled and unable to entertain themselves. Which...yes.

I'm going to go on a limb here though, and say that balance is probably the key.


Comments

 

Lisa said:

And along comes this article to make you feel even crappier....  I tend to agree -- balance and common sense are key.  If you enjoy playing with your kid, then by all means do it and for the love of whatever don't feel guilty!  

I'm sorry, but playing with your kid can't be that bad.  Anything that brings the two of you closer can't be so awful.  I'm not talking hovering/smothering here btw.  That's a different story and the other end of the spectrum.  

July 24, 2007 5:36 PM
 

carfree childhood said:

but balance and common sense don't sell books or get you on talk shows.

July 24, 2007 9:19 PM
 

doodaddy said:

"Not on the natural order of things?" How freakishly stupid. You know what else isn't on the natural order of things? Hygiene. Education. Fitness. Play with your kids is enormously beneficial, but perhaps more palatable if we call it "teaching?" Personally, I don't see the difference.

July 24, 2007 9:27 PM
 

Grammy said:

Have you evere tried playing Barbies with a little kid?  You just don't have the same imagination that they do.  Our stories are way more complex than anything they can come up with.  I say, unless it is a game with rules?  Let them play with someone else.

July 24, 2007 10:54 PM
 

Angel said:

Well WHEW I don't feel like such a slacker mom this summer ;)

Seriously, I have some chronic illnesses and I've felt guilty for not being more involved in the kids' activities.  But at the same time, we do spend alot of time together as a family, so I think doing an activity (like sports) independently is good for them as well.

July 24, 2007 11:47 PM
 

chattydaddy said:

it seems logical that fathers should engage in the kind of play that we most enjoy -- rolling around, rough housing, pillow fights, building castles, and so on. And of course teaching them words, for which they seem to have a ravenous appetite.

i think the person above has a good point -- all that is natural or historical is not necessarily good. IQs have been getting higher over time, probably because children a receiving a lot more stimulous. i know parents love to talk about not engaging in IQ competition, but the truth is most of us want our kids to have powerful brains that will help them have successful satisfying lives in the competitive modern marketplace.

all that said, it IS somewhat reassuring to know that many other parents find much kid play mind numbingly boring. i know that i can be super engaged for a half hour per day, and several hours in the weekends. i can't do much more than that without being frustrated, and i think one of the gifts i can give my son is a fulfilled father. interesting article ...

July 26, 2007 10:16 AM

About Patti

Visit my personal blog at childbearinghipster.com

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • drool.icio.us

    The top million must-have baby products.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage