Strollerderby

Organic Food: Not As Great As We Think?

Posted by Karen Murphy

organic produceI've been paying the extra bucks and feeding my kids organically-grown foods for years now, because like many parents, I believe that pesticide-free food is better for small developing bodies that are less likely to be able to effectively assimilate chemicals. I know, too, that eating locally is also "better": not only does it help support your local economy via mostly small family farmers, but energetically it's preferable as well (stay with me here: this is macrobiotic theory), as your body can better use the energy from foods from your climactic and geographical region.

But how to balance the two? Typically, the organic produce I see in, say, Whole Foods isn't local (nor, mostly, is the other stuff, but that's beside the point). So, is it a big deal? Why yes, it is, actually, if part of your reason for eating organically also has to do with the environment and the chemicals released through large-farm production. Because guess what?  The environmental cost for organically-grown produce may actually be higher than conventionally-grown produce. Grown without pesticides and herbicides, organically-grown produce is more labor-intensive (think about all those weeds in your own garden), and the cheapest labor is the farthest away, at least if you live in North America.

Yikes! Makes you think, doesn't it? It does me. Right now is a good time, seasonally speaking, to be thinking about making changes, as there are in most areas plentiful options that are local, and in most cases, cheaper: farmer's markets, CSAs, local family farms. But what about the rest of the year? Unless you have your own space for gardening and grow enough to put up the excess for the winter, it's a quandary. I guess it's time to decide how much that kiwi and that mango means to you in January, let alone those strawberries.

[original article pointed by Karen Rani guesting at The Zero Boss


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Kaz said:

There is definitely a growing movement toward "eating locally" ... the food is fresher, the impact on the environment is lesser... but I see eating organic as two-fold: (1) the impact the pesticides have on the local environment, and (2) the impact they have on your body. And you've mentioned both here.

Certainly, the ideal situation is to get local organic produce. That isn't always an option for everyone.

I think information like this helps people deciding whether to buy imported organics or whether to buy locally.

Unfortunately, I think a lot of people still purchase imported, non-organic foods.

I think some people who purchase organic foods are also supporting the idea of organic foods. The hope here is that one day, more and more local (or at least US) farms will make the move toward organic growing.

It is funny you mention strawberries, because those are one of the fruits most likely to retain pesticides, and probably are one of the foods you should choose organic over local.

Thanks again for keeping these issues (and green parenting) up to date on Babble! You guys reach a lot more people than I do.

June 14, 2007 2:04 PM
 

Ryan Pitman said:

Serious? It's beside the point that the conventional food isn't local either? That kind of seems to nullify the entire point of the comparison.

June 14, 2007 3:01 PM
 

Phiya said:

The article you cited in this story is distorted by only looking at transportation effects and by not taking into account the overall effect of agricultural chemicals on the environment, which happen to be the greatest cause of environmental destruction on the planet, far beyond the transportation industry  It is not a case of "either/or".  Both the CO2 output from the transportation industry AND conventional agriculture are damaging to the environment.  Until there is a better way to transport things people should still choose organic over conventional and they should choose local organic over non-local organic.

June 14, 2007 8:08 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage