Strollerderby

Attachment Parenting: Giving Kids a Sense of Security or Entitlement?

Posted by Alisyn

Attachment Parenting is becoming pretty mainstream these days - the slings-wearers, the breast feeders, the co-sleepers: they're everywhere!  AP is an idea that is so old, it's new again, and most parents today practice AP in some form or another.  Thanks in part to mainstream magazines like Mothering, HipMama and good ol' Dr. Sears, it is now fairly common to breast feed on demand, co-sleep, and wear your baby.  These are all positive things.  But what happens when attachment parenting lets you down? 

BadBadIvy, over at Love Shak, Baby recently posted a rarely-heard take on attachment parenting that I feel like I could have written myself.  In her post, How the AP Movement Gave My Daughter a Sense of Entitlement, Ivy explores the idea that perhaps anticipating her daughter's every need, and rarely separating from her until the age of 3, may have contributed to her daughter's evolution into a demanding little diva.  Ivy is quick to point out that she doesn't blame AP, so much as she wonders how much attachment parenting, combined with her daughter's innate personality and temperament, played a part in her growing into "the exact definition of diva. She expects things to go her way, and she wants that to happen right now. She also wants to be with me every second of every day."

BadBadIvy has done her research: her older son is a "traditionally" parented kid: bottle fed, slept in a crib from the get-go.  Her youngest was breast fed, but left on his own a little more.  Both are easy going, mild-tempered kids.  Her middle child, her daughter, her AP baby, is the one who needs more - all the time.  Ivy wonders, "Was this a result of attachment parenting or was this predetermined personality? I think the diva predisposition was there, but I do think APing her pushed her over the edge of divadom. Children need more independence than the AP way allows for. Attachment parenting can make parents slaves to their children.

My personal experience with AP is similar.  I nursed on demand and co-slept with both my kids, but was more "attached" to my older daughter, and she to me.  She is a highly sensitive person, and has always been high-needs, literally since the day she came home from the hospital.  I often wonder if my drive to parent her in the AP fashion arose from her high-needs personality, or if her personality drove me to find alternative ways of caring for her.  Would she be more easy going if today, if I had let her operate a little more independently as a baby/toddler?  Would she be less easy going if I'd not tended to what I perceived to be her needs as I had?  It's like the chicken and the egg.  The younger girl was left to cry a little more, roll around on the floor a little longer, passed off to friends and family a little more freely - and she is a mellower, more even-keeled kid for it.

I really sympathize with BadBadIvy here.  I believe in attachment parenting - or rather, my take some/leave some version of it - but I wonder: is there such a thing as being too attached for a kid's own good?

What have your experiences with AP been?  What would you do differently?  What do you love about it?

[Thanks to The Zero Boss for turning us on to Ivy's post] 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

RachelZ said:

Too bad there's no way to REALLY know!  I wouldn't call myself an AP parent, necessarily, though I use Dr Sears and other AP references.  My kid is totally mellow and chill (which notable exceptions), but I can't decide if it's because she's just made that way or if it's because I'm consciously trying to relax and mellow out myself with her or what.  

I breast-fed on demand until she bit me and drew blood then it was bottles all the way.  I carried her around quite a bit when she was teeny, but now she rolls all over the place and I don't pick her up every time she crashes into something or cries.

So I don't know.  It's totally impossible to figure this one out because no two kids are alike and no two parenting styles are exactly alike.  

May 8, 2007 9:45 AM
 

Ivy said:

Interesting. My daughter was really high needs too. She cried 7 or more hours a day every day until she started talking. Now she spends 7 or more hours a day talking, haha.

May 8, 2007 10:13 AM
 

Andrew said:

My wife and I found some things about AP really difficult - especially night times. However now that our son is four he seems to be very well adjusted (we're somewhat biased of course) - he goes to sleep by himself, sleeps all night, is fine with a little separation (like if one of us is away for business) because he knows that we'll be there for him if he needs us and that we'll be responsive.

So it feels like it was quite an investment but it seems to be paying off so far.

May 8, 2007 11:46 AM
 

crunchy said:

I don't know....is it attachment parenting or just 21st Century Parenting.

We do seem to 'give in' more to our kids...are perhaps more focused on their needs and wants as compared to past generations.

I can't label myself as any type of parent...Adam was bottle fed and slept in a bassinet mostly..beside our bed.  We cant' get him out of our bed and his sense of entitlement is enourmous.

Caity lived in a sling on me for the first few months till I couldn't carry her anymore, yet is happy in her bed alone...but again thinks she runs the show.

So did we parent differently or just respond to their needs from day one and now look where we are?

May 8, 2007 12:09 PM
 

ji said:

When my son was born I had never heard of AP, but it turns out that I borrowed a lot from it. However, I was never dogmatic and it was a balance of what was best for the entire family, taking into consideration our different personalities and physical and emotional needs. I think its important to  teach this outlook to the kid, so that as baby grows she/he can respect themself and others. And also learn to critically evaluate different situations and make reasonable decisions, both short and long term.

May 8, 2007 12:44 PM
 

ji said:

Also, with regards to the featured photo: I can  not imagine myself choosing to carry a toddler and an baby in a sling at the same time. Mom's back has priorites over kid's unwillingness to walk or ride in a stroller. I'm so glad that my kids ages are going to be 5.5 years apart.

May 8, 2007 12:51 PM
 

Kristen said:

Balance & Moderation that is the key. Every parent will look back on the time when their kids were little and wish they had done something different. It never fails. No body is perfect and even when you have the fourth kid, like me, and think you've got it all figured out, life throws you a curve ball and you wonder....."what did I do wrong".  Attachment parenting was not really for me but if it works for some then great! To each his own.

May 8, 2007 12:54 PM
 

Mom2Two said:

I love Dr Sears and I love attachment parenting...for me.  Do people really think that there is one way, and one way only, to raise kids?  The way I look at it is to do what makes you happy.  If you don't want to cosleep, don't do it.  Nothing about AP says you give in to yor child's every whim too.  I breastfeed my 5 month old on demand, but my toddler doesn't get cheese curls every single time he asks for them.  I play with him a lot, but he has had to learn, snce the birth of the baby, that sometimes he needs to wait.  It works for us, and he's well adjusted, independant and happy.

May 8, 2007 1:45 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage