Strollerderby

It's OUR Bed, Dammit: Co-Sleeping by Default

When I was a child, we were only allowed to wake the parents in cases of extreme weather, suspected haunting by ghosts, or extreme physical distress.  Otherwise, their bedroom was off limits.  This rule was instituted following my discovery of the "massager" I'd found in my parent's nightstand.  The lock on their door showed up the next day and foiled further attempts to find even greater discoveries.

The Family Bed is as old as oatmeal but has found greater traction among Gen X than the Boomers before them.  And it makes me wonder: what the hell are we thinking? I truly understand giving kids comfort and love during the night as well as during the day. And when babies are small and new and hungry, nursing them in bed is convenient and promotes better sleep for mom and baby.

But at what point does it get out of hand? 

Alisyn reached her limit when her daughter turned three. The New York Times reports that some parents end up sharing beds with their kids out of desperation and describes a new category of parent with whom I totally sympathize, the "reluctant co-sleeper." 

There is apparently now an entire industry devoted to helping families sort through various sleep problems, many of which are outlined in the Times piece.  How is it that top attorneys, gallery owners, and CEOs cannot manage the boundaries and structure necessary to get kids back in their own beds?

I think the problem is in the power. Parents who exercise power during the day are most likely so wiped out in the evening or on the weekends that they have insufficient energy to devote to whipping those ankle-biters into shape. And tired parents are understandably more interested in having their kids in bed than in disrupting sleep night after night in order to get the kid back into bed.  I could also be that we've become a generation that has completely lost site of the difference between loving our children and LOVING our children.  I predict divorce rates will soon be skyrocketing unless we figure out a way to get Billy back into his own goddamn bed!


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

birdgal said:

I have never understood the equation of having your child sleep in their own bed to emotional abuse (I am clearly not a Dr. Sears fan).  My parents didn't let me in their bed except when I was overly scared or sick and even then they'd try everything before letting me stay there.  Despite this 'horrible' treatment, I have no lasting emotional scars (at least I don't think so!).  It's one thing if you WANT to co-sleep but good christ people if it's taking over your life (and you don't really want to be co-sleeping), take a week to be sleep-deprived and get those kids to sleep in their own beds.  Then all the haggling and negotiating with your kids will be over and done with and you can actually get some sleep!

March 6, 2007 11:45 AM
 

Sheri said:

If you WANT your children to sleep with you--fine.  Go for it.....but if you don't want them in your bed, why are they there???  I never did the co-sleeping thing with any of my children--even as infants.  I think I was too scared I'd roll over on them, the dogs would jump on them or something.  We did put their crib in our room, but that's another blog.  Even now, the kids don't really want to sleep with us--not to say they don't get up but we try to soothe them back to sleep in their own room.  I wouldn't feel guilty about getting your children to sleep in their own beds.  Not being sleep deprived probably makes it easier to be a patient parent during the day.

March 6, 2007 12:02 PM
 

squawks said:

I think that "loving vs. LOVING" idiom doesn't mean what you think it means.

March 6, 2007 12:25 PM
 

squakws said:

Oh, and on the subject of the family bed: the answer is boundaries. I was allowed to sneak into my parents' bed after the occasional nightmare, during lightning storms and that sort of thing, but at no point did it occur to me that I could (or would want to) make a more regular habit of it. I grew up knowing they were there if I needed them, and that I was welcome in their bed when I needed a cuddle now and then, but I wouldn't have wanted to bunk with them every night. The disturbing trend I see these days is that nobody's talking about establishing balance and boundaries. Everything really IS cool in moderation. Why not teach our kids *that* -- across the board -- instead of treating every parenting issue as a slippery slope?

March 6, 2007 12:30 PM
 

crunchy carpets said:

I don't think it is fair to say that tired parents giving into the kids at night will add to the divorce rate.

If both parents are at the point when they just don't care..then it is still a mutual agreement and they also know it WON'T last for ever.

March 6, 2007 12:47 PM
 

ZeitgeistMama said:

I'll come out and say that we LIKE the family bed! We co-slept the whole night for the first 18 months, then we moved and took the opportunity to start our son in his own bed (not even a crib!) for the beginning of the night, and when he wakes up, he comes and gets in bed with us.

It works great when he comes in around 2 a.m., less good when it's 10 p.m. and we aren't asleep yet, at which point we put him back in his own bed. But my god, i wouldn't want to be trying to put him back to sleep in his own bed at 2 a.m.!

And now he's 2, so we're working on keeping him in his own bed consistently until after we've gone to sleep, with some success.

He certainly knows which is his bed, and which is mommy and daddy's bed, and we really enjoy having him sleep with us (most of the time!).

So if it's working for us, then who's to say it's not a good thing?

March 6, 2007 1:01 PM
 

VancouverMama said:

I am one of those children who were forbidden from entering her parents' room and I suffered many nights of sleeplessness as a child, which set a pattern of insomnia that lasted well into my thirties. I wish I'd been welcome into their bed for no reason other than "I can't sleep." My husband and I are co-sleeping with our eight-month old, and while we don't want her in our bed forever, I want her to grow up knowing that she is always welcome with us if she is feeling scared or anxious.

One thing that is working well for us now is putting her into her crib and not bringing her into our bed until she wakes in the early morning. Some nights it's 1:30 am; last night it was  4 am.

March 6, 2007 1:04 PM
 

karrie said:

I resemble this, a bit.

We coslept by choice with our son when he was an infant. When it no longer worked, we transitioned him to his own room. All was well for a year or so, then bang. Night terrors.

Guess which room I'm sleeping in now?

My husband is such an inveterate night-owl that I doubt where I sleep really effects our love life. He's up until all hours watching DVR and doing geeky guy stuff.

March 6, 2007 1:40 PM
 

Xdm said:

Ok. that's us. Dude (2.5) goes to sleep in his own bed but then wakes up around 3 or 4 and hollers for us to come get him. This has been the pattern for about two weeks.

But you know what? Last night I let him holler for a few minutes and he fell back asleep until about 6. Genius!  I, however stayed awake for about another hour wondering why he wasn't yelling and if he was ok.  I wonder how tonight will go....

March 6, 2007 5:09 PM
 

The Parenting Buzz on Clipgator : The Co-Sleeping Conundrum : ClipGator.com said:

March 6, 2007 6:15 PM
 

Holmes said:

We've been doing the cosleeping thing with our son (now 16 months) since he was born, pretty much because it was all that worked, and we grew to like having him there with us.  I can see the time coming, though, that we'll want him out.  People keep telling us "good luck getting him out", as if he's a stray terrier that we threw a few scraps to and now won't get away from our door.  Sure, the transition may not be easy, but I'm skeptical that it's going to be any more of a challenge than any other sleep-related issue with kids.  

March 7, 2007 3:36 PM
 

Jewess » Mommy-Blog Roundup: Book Review, Rude Supermarket Staff, Dads Who Don’t Do Diaper Duty, Rants on Irresponsible Parenting said:

March 8, 2007 9:30 AM
 

Strollerderby said:

Brass tacks. There were some serious discussions happening this week, centering around a few always controversial topics: Christianity, Breeder v. Non-Breeders, co-sleeping, immigration, and the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. First, Alisyn's post about

March 10, 2007 4:37 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

Attachment parents (APs), those lovely kind souls mean well. They do. But sometimes following the tenets of perfect childrearing can cause irreparable harm to the marriage upon which the children ultimately depend. Marriages struggle after kids, there's

May 7, 2007 11:04 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage