Strollerderby

Kids With Lawns are Skinnier, Study Says

Posted by Karen Murphy

park play kidsI really thought that all the issues surrounding kids and their relative fatness had been covered.  I really did.  I was hoping they had.  After all, how many ways can you tell us that kids are fat because of the junk they eat and the fact that they don't exercise?  But I was wrong.  It turns out there is yet another study and it suggests that kids who live where there is a lawn or a park are thinner than kids who don't.

Here's a recap of what the new study is all about:  7,334 children between the ages of 3 and 18 were studied who lived in Marion County, Indiana., and it was determined whether they were overweight by calculating their body mass index (which we already know is a suspicious number).  They also looked at amounts of green landscapes near each child's home as well as the relative proximity to retail food establishments.  Exercise habits were not studied, which I think is a major failing, but it was determined that kids living in more highly-populated areas tended to be fatter than kids living around more green areas like parks and lawns.

They should have studied kids in Paris.  The only fat people I ever saw there were Americans, and everyone walks everywhere, and there aren't a lot of parks but the ones there are sure get used from what I could see, even in winter.   As I see it, this is a social problem, not an environmental one.  It seems to me that people are looking for answers in the wrong places (and spending an awful lot of money on useless studies).


+ DIGG + STUMBLE
Posted Feb 17 2007, 09:22 AM
Filed under: , ,

Comments

 

LushMommy said:

I own my house but my son rarely goes out in the yard: my neighbor two doors down is the block's official cat lady and my front garden unfortunately their litter box. My 2-year-old is still skinny in spite of being house-bound.

February 17, 2007 11:54 AM
 

transplanted nyer said:

Yes, these studies are really stupid.  We moved to the South of France a few years ago from NYC.  I have actually become fatter in the "country" (although having another baby did not help), though am not fat (nor are my kids or husband).  I have always thought - and now am really convinced - that living in the city keeps you thin.  In NYC, we didn't own a car and walked everywhere - to stores, work, play. Here in the country (though the quality of food is much, much, better) we don't get enough daily excercise.  I cannot wait to move to Paris next year.  Physically and psycically (diversity) much healthier.  

February 17, 2007 3:50 PM
 

Sheri said:

Yes, I'm a fat girl.  Used to be a skinny one, married a big guy.  For some reason, we have normal sized kiddies.  I'm guessing it is because I make sure they eat right, and get the exercize they need.  I, on the other hand, eat when I can and run after them.  I'm working on the whole fat thing, but that's another blog.  I don't know why some kids are fat while others are thin.  We have been known to eat at McDonalds once a month or so, we also have snack foods sitting around the house--lots of fruit and good stuff, but also cookies and graham crackery kiddie stuff.  I just signed the 4 year-old up for soccer.  Hopefully, they will remain thin.  We live near several parks and we have a small backyard.    I wonder though, if sometimes people just try to find this stuff.  People are different.  Everyone has one of those annoying friends who eat like a friggin horse and gain nothing, and a friend who eats like a bird and exersizes like a wild woman who can't get rid of the last 10 lbs in her hips and butt.  Everything in moderation and usually things will be alright.

February 17, 2007 5:09 PM
 

MissB said:

Now I need a lawn?  Jesus fucking christ.  I'm still working on getting a washer and dryer.  

Fuck these studies.  Nobody ever knocks on MY door, asks me if I have a lawn (laffo, like you'd need to ask) and then weighs my kids.  I've decided that since I'm never invited to be one of the test subjects that all these studies are all bullshit.

February 18, 2007 8:13 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage