Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

California Considers A Ban on Spanking

Posted by JasonAvant

I don't agree with spanking. Sugar coat it all you want, it's still hitting a child with the intent of using both pain and the fear of pain as a means of punishment. Spanking is one of the few parenting choices that I'll pass judgment on. It's pretty simple - you hit a kid, that makes you the worst kind of coward.

So you'd think I'd be happy over a recent bit of news, that California Assemblywoman Sally Lieber is planning on introducing a bill that would make it a crime for parents to spank their child, provided the child is 3 or younger. Those caught in the act would face up to a year in jail, along with fines. The bill would extend the state's corporal punishment laws, which make it illegal for anyone but parents to spank a child - wow, are there still schools that allow "swats"? I got paddled by the principal when I was in the fourth grade, and it truly sucked; hurt like a bitch and very humiliating. Ah well, the principal was about 60 then, so there's a good chance that these days, she's enjoying her retirement...in the fires of Hell.

Back to the proposed law. No, I don't like spanking. But to pass a law against it solves nothing. How would it be enforced? (Yeah, I know, the Bush administration has already placed wiretaps and hidden cameras in most of our houses anyway, so it just becomes a matter of who to send the tapes to.) How much of a burden would this place on an already overtaxed court and prison system? Even though I think people who hit their kids are pussies (and, in the case of the folks who run this particular website, delusional psychotics), I don't think throwing them in jail for a year is the answer. Perhaps our tax dollars and resources should be used to help parents who are looking for ways to discipline their kids that don't involve violence; I'd rather see my state do more to help educate parents on alternative means of correcting their kids' behavior.


Comments

 

Alisyn said:

Yeah, this is pretty much bullshit.  There's no way to enforce this in the households that *really* need it to work, and jailing abusive parents, instead of being proactive and educating them on how better to discipline their children is do depressingly... American.

January 19, 2007 12:43 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

What is up with lawmakers these days? Is there not enough broken shiznit in their own communities to

February 15, 2007 4:18 PM

About JasonAvant

Jason Avant is the Founder and Managing Editor of DadCentric, a groundbreaking and popular blog that, according to his agent, provides an offbeat look at events and issues that affect today's fathers. He also writes for Maya's Mom, and his personal blog, Pet Cobra. Jason lives and works in San Diego, Calif. with his wife and two-year old son. His hobbies include surfing, skateboarding, muttering under his breath, haggis tasting, macrame', and writing short descriptions about himself in the third person.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • drool.icio.us

    The top million must-have baby products.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage