Droolicious

Consumer Reports Picks 5 Baby Gifts Never to Buy Again

Posted by Aaron Burgess

Baby Sling Carrier: 1 of 5 Unsafe Baby Products Looked at in a New Consumer Reports Blog Entry

Sling carriers! Oh, how we speak of them here at Droolicious. And while we're talking new baby products, we've also covered our share of bath seats, bumper pads and sleep positioners -- all items that, thanks to a new blog post from Consumer Reports, we may never look at the same way again.

In the post, titled "Five products not to buy for your baby," CR focuses on the potential safety hazards behind all of these commonly purchased items. While some of the products -- bedside sleepers, for example -- were singled out because of specific death-related safety recalls, the false sense of security many such products give to new parents ended up being more the focus with others.

Take, for example, this eye-opening excerpt about slings: "Over the past past five years, at least four babies died and there have been many reports of serious injury associated with the use of sling-type carriers. The incidents include skull fractures, head injuries, contusions and abrasions." Granted, a majority of these injuries occurred when the little ones slipped out of their slings, but the post brings up an interesting point about the need for widespread sling-carrier safety standards.

You tell us: Does this news have you cautious, or are you keeping that sling and bath seat on your registry? [Consumer Reports]


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

ashersmom said:

Seems to me that 3 out of the 5 products mentioned have had problems due to parental neglect, not due to defects in the product.  

April 23, 2009 1:41 PM
 

t's mom said:

amen ashersmom.

April 23, 2009 3:42 PM
 

baby babie said:

i do question the use of baby slings as a baby carry base an the one position the baby is in at all time........i think the baby can be come handicap...................

April 23, 2009 6:09 PM
 

momtobe said:

Most of the mums I know use the slings and love them - so I think they're probably fine in most cases. Having said that, I'm absolutely paranoid about them...always have been, I can literally picture the baby slipping out and onto her head. But then I'm scared of hammocks for myself (more for fear of the humiliation than the head injury) and don't even get me started on carnival rides. So I won't be using one because of my weird little fears, but when you think of the millions of times they're used every week and the number of injuries/deaths - probably not that unsafe - for other people!

April 24, 2009 12:50 PM
 

Courtney said:

I think slings are great...people just have to be aware of their limitations.  If we're going to stop buying any product that has ever been related to an infant death, that's going to outlaw basically everything.

April 24, 2009 1:12 PM
 

Whozat said:

Most baby carriers, <I>if used correctly</I> are very safe - but I've seen some independent studies of bag slings (like the one shown in the photo) that show that they put a baby (especially a newborn) in a very bad position, in terms of its airway, and also close up around the baby, preventing the free flow of air. Pocket slings, ring slings and other types of carriers don't have that problem.

April 24, 2009 1:55 PM
 

Amoret said:

Actually, baby babie, certain slings are designed to allow the baby to be worn in a variety of positions to accommodate the changing needs of a growing child (unlike, say, the Baby Bjorn).   I wore my daughter in a sling from birth until she was old enough to walk on her own.  That said, I was very careful, and I almost always supported the sling with one hand.

April 24, 2009 1:58 PM
 

tammy said:

i was freaked out about slings because they were one sided and totally open - i figured i lean over to get something and baby falls out. plus what's the point if you always use one hand to support it - where is your Hands Free concept? anwyay - that's why i succumbed to using a wrap, and then ulitmately was so thrilled when i found this new double sling that i now swear by - solved the worry i had that CR i think is mainly talking about. so they should probably not be so general about SLINGS but maybe explain a bit that some sling carriers are safer than others.

April 24, 2009 2:09 PM
 

anna said:

oh my, we never would have made it through my little one's infancy without our Moby Wrap! I agree with others, you need to be an informed consumer, know the product's limitations, and do your best. There are too many things to worry about...

April 24, 2009 2:21 PM
 

MomOf2 said:

i don't think i would have gotten a bit of sanity if i wasn't wearing my baby ktan all the time. for consumer reports to write that is pretty far fetched when the good outweighs the bad. plus every sling is designed differently, they should just say that parents should check the safety standards the company abides by before they purchase a sling/carrier.

April 24, 2009 2:38 PM
 

HealthyHappyBaby said:

They are talking about slings here not wraps like the Moby Wrap or a baby carrier like the Ergo.  These are quite different from slings.  By the way the Baby Bjorn is also not healthy for very young babies as it forces them to hold their heads and neck in a stiff, upright position which can tense their young muscles and cause damage over time.  I've also heard that some pediatrician say it places their hips in an unhealthy position.

Also, here's a post from another mom that may be helpful:

" I’m sorry but the Bjorn does NOT put a baby in the optimal posistion as a previous poster wrote. Legs spread is not the main concern. A babies legs should never just dangle as it puts too much pressure on the back and spine of the child. The appropriate way is to have the babies knees as high as his/her body with the fabric cupping their bottom. NOT dangling around with just a strip of fabric around their crotch to hold them up.

Newborns and younger infants (older babies too) do great in wraps like a Moby or a sling such as Slinglings. Mei tais are also wonderful for all ages and stages of babyhood and are my families go to carrier. (Look at Babyhawk and Ball Baby carriers for examples)

Please do your research before buying a carrier! Try a few out and find what works best for you AND your baby!"  

April 24, 2009 4:07 PM
 

Lalahem said:

I bought that sling pictured for my girls, none of the babies liked it.  We ended up making a sit up sling style carrier that supported the baby in an upright position, that both my granddaughters absolutely loved and it aided in the bonding process.

April 24, 2009 4:09 PM
 

ncavillones said:

Most injuries are a result of parental neglect, so maybe CR should issue a ban against stupid parents.

April 24, 2009 8:32 PM
 

old mom said:

A new born boy  in my community died from suffocation while being carried in a sling about five years ago. The mom, an older (40 plus) lady put her baby in the sling and went out for a walk. When she reached her destination the child was dead.  She then spent the next few years pressuring the coroners office to change the cause of death from suffocation to crib death which he ultimately did, mostly to make her feel better.  The whole thing was so sad.

April 25, 2009 12:30 AM
 

EllaAnne said:

I carry my kids in ring slings and pocket slings and whatever I can grab on the way out. And when they are teency, I am always double checking them. Luckily, they are usually snoring.

And those giant ugly evenflo bag slings are AWFUL, and really uncomfortable for mom and baby. They put a seatbelt thing in them, so you can't customize it at all. That particular type should be illegal for the dangerous design.

April 25, 2009 3:59 PM
 

E said:

We used a (new 2007) sling from Infantino for our newborn daughter. She loved it; we found it easy to use, and quite safe and reliable. Its interior harness was very stable and comfortable for the baby. I did find myself being careful about which way the baby faced, so as to be assured she could breathe properly. But I don't know how I would have managed those early weeks without it. When she was fussy, the only thing we could count on to calm her down was putting her in the sling.

Basically everything under the sun is a threat to a baby. I think the key is parental diligence, which is difficult and sucky but there you are.

April 25, 2009 4:11 PM
 

Michelle said:

I don't how I would have survived my first born without the babysling.  I had a new native baby carrier and he lived in that thing until he wanted to walk.  It was great for nursing! And my second child who is a twin, demanded to be close to me at all times and I would not been able to do anything without that sling.  And I have a friend who is an occupational therapist and she said that slings were better for babys spine than the Bjorn.

May 11, 2009 5:43 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage